Search

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Outdoor seating
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Odd Fellows Cafe Reviews - 37

4.5
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Chris Trethewey

Odd Fellows Cafe, located on Block Island, is a nice cafe located right off the main street across from the port. I ordered an iced coffee, which was tasty. There is a nice patio that overlooks the harbor, which made for a quick rest spot as we were exploring the island on bikes. Plus, the staff was friendly.

Jeff McHugh

I’ve never seen this cafe before and I was recovering from an Easter bender and needed some caffeine before trudging through Block Island sound on the way back to the mainland.

This was the best metaphorical Easter egg that I could hope to find! Great spot, friendly staff, and amazing iced coffee/food. Thanks to you Odd Fellows!

Jordan Wagner

Their cranberry lemon tart bars were amazing. They make all of their offerings in house and they are fantastic! It was even gluten free, I'm not, but it didn't taste any less good. Amazing if you get the chance, stop in and get one, or two!

Autumn Marie

Busy café, steps off the ferry. Whoa, jarring noise alert! Barista was SLAMMING espresso grounds from the filter into metal trash, yikes too early for like random gunshot sounds. Friendly suggestion - buy a knock box its quieter ;) Great Smoothie and GF Lemon Bread! Large Breakfast egg sandwich on Sourdough bread, decent. Hardworking, courteous staff looked exhausted at end of season (sending hugs). See you next year :) :) :)

Kristen Dority

Great coffee, smoothies (my kids had to go back for the best smoothie ever), awesome people. Upstairs seating area is so beautiful, creative and whimsical- we ended up staying much longer, lots of good memories here.
(My matcha latte was perfect. It’s hard to find unsweetened version at Starbucks or Peet’s.)

Melissa Damon Hayes

Amazing food! We got the chicken Philly and Marty. My husband and I loved our food so much, we traded each other the second half just to see if the other got just as good of a meal...and we did. My son got a pretzel dog and my mother got broccoli chowder soup. Honestly, the best food I've had in a long time and not that pricey. I believe we paid about 38 for everything.

Joseph Camara

Odd Fellows has a great atmosphere, and is open year round on Block Island. Very friendly staff and delicious food would come back.

Chris Biestek

One of the best breakfast sandwiches I've ever had at a restaurant. Such an easy going atmosphere with a small, but great selection of drinks and food.

Julie Sellew

The perfect spot for grabbing coffee, breakfast sandwiches, smoothies, etc. Their chicken salad sandwich on a croissant paired with chips is my favorite beach day meal! They also offer gluten free goodies which has been a game changer for my son with celiac. On our most recent visit to BI, we arrived midday and all the GF treats were sold out but the baker offered to make him something - his choice! - to be available the following morning. Going out of her way to make GF chocolate chip cookies was so incredibly kind and it made our entire trip. We will be back time and time again!

Nicole

Located right across the street from the ferry dock, so many options from coffee, teas, lattes, bubble tea, gluten free pastries too! Did not have any of their breakfast & lunch sandwiches but they sound great.

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload

Odd Fellows Cafe Hours

  • Monday 7 AM to 3 PM
  • Tuesday 7 AM to 3 PM
  • Wednesday 7 AM to 3 PM
  • Thursday 7 AM to 3 PM
  • Friday 7 AM to 3 PM
  • Saturday 7 AM to 3 PM
  • Sunday 7 AM to 3 PM