Reviews (100)
Food was great. Service was what you would want. Quick, friendly, efficient, knowledgeable of the menu and specials.
My teen daughter and I stopped in for dinner last night. The food was amazing, the service was great and we really enjoyed the live music! Highly recommend this spot to everyone!!
Have eaten here about six times and die Thing has always been undercooked or just ‘off’. Overpriced for what you get and lack of quality and consistency.
This was a great night
*UPDATE: The arancini is probably the best appetizer in Sheridan! The waitress we've had the past few times we've visited is super bubbly and attentive. Loving the new Italian menu! This is the new date night spot* Love the pizza! Wasn't impressed with the ramen. Appetizers are pretty good depending on what you get. Great atmosphere but if a band is playing it gets too loud.
Came in on a slow night. Very accommodating for a serious food allergy. Great food with lots of flavor.
I finally tried this place out last week and was pleasantly surprised. I had one of their fancy pizzas and a hand crafted cocktail. I sat at the bar and got great service. The bartender was talented and professional. I will be a return customer.
A tad pricey but good.
Some changes since I was last here. Surprisingly, it even was even a better atmosphere than last visit. Sit down dining, with a great, new Italian menu. Excellent service!
Really good Italian food for Sheridan. The menu is all Italian dishes. Used to be more diverse which we prefer Service has been consistently good. Last visit most patrons we're wearing winter coats while dining. It was cold.
Great place,
Gorgeous decor. Every dish was gourmet!! The cocktails were off the chart. Staff was engaging and timely. Live music? Yes, please! We’ll be back
Had take out. Very friendly staff. Food was excellent. Definitely a place to try when you re in town!
We were there on a Wednesday and was served in the smaller coffee room. It was very quiet and quaint. However on Saturday it was not. They had a three piece band that was too loud at 6:00 pm. You couldn’t hear each other. We did move outside. That helped. However the food came out cold. Very disappointed.
While staying nearby at the lovely Sheridan Inn, we twice dined here. Avocado toast and scrambled eggs for breakfast. Delicious coffee. Fig, prosciutto, blue cheese pizza and a garlicky Caesar salad for dinner. Both meals were perfectly excellent. The atmosphere in this renovated train station is very upscale and modern. The sprawling layout does challenge the staff as they bustle over so much square footage. Still, be patient. This is a very worthwhile restaurant with truly delicious food.
Was there last Sunday and only the cafe area was open because of a staff shortage. Couldn't order anything from the cafe area and there 3 or 4 items from the Italian menu that we couldn't order because they were out of the product. The food I had was descent...not outstanding like I normally have there. This new boring Italian menu, cheesy red and white checkered table cloths, and cafe need to reopen. I'll give them one more shot but if nothing has changed, it'll be my last time going.
UPDATED: We went back to Wecome Market Hall for their incredible pizza and 2 side salads and were told they no longer serve side salads and we'd need to chose a salad from the menu (this was after the waitress asked the kitchen). Three weeks ago, the restaurant responded to my original review and told me that they will do side salads. We left and I am changing the rating from 4 to 2 stars. (The 2 stars are there only because the pizza is so good but pizza is not a complete meal for us.) We will not be back. ORIGINAL REVIEW FOR PIZZA ONLY: This was one of the best brick oven pizzas we have ever had. We consider ourselves "brick oven pizza snobs" and this was an incredible pizza. The tomatoes were the star and so flavorful. The crust was thin and cooked just right with lightly burnt bubbles. We also had local brewery beer on tab (Blacktooth Amber Ale). The only reason for removing a star from our rating was the lack of a dinner salad to accompany the pizza. (The 2 salads offered on the menu didn't hit the mark.)
Wonderful building and good meal. Who could ask for anything more!
I recently had a large group dinner reservations here. They accommodated my large party easily, great communication, even moved us inside for a quick dinner table transition when the weather hit. Quick on gettin us our meals, and wonderful drinks! We thoroughly enjoyed ourselves and will be back. Thank you!
Don't know what kind of food there is until you walk in. Work on that or you will fold.