Reviews (100)
Unfortunately despite all of the rave reviews I've read, this was one of the worst meals I've ever had. Upon walking in, the interior is understandably dated, and decorated here and there with Cowboy Americana. Once youve been sat though, it becomes clear that the sanitation of the establishment is severely lacking. Tables were not being wiped down between seatings, and cups were being stored still wet and ripe for bacterial growth. This is just the start of the bare minimum attitude this establishment has. The waitress is the one saving grace of this place, merrily serving all of the tables herself, and she swiftly took my order of a Mushroom Swiss Chicken Fried Steak. It came out shortly after as a literal hot mess, white gravy spilling off the side of the plate and onto the table below. Bon Appétit. For what it's worth, the Chicken Fried Steak itself was passable, though a pepperier gravy would have hit the spot. The true detriment were the sides, which were neigh unpalatable. The mashed potatoes were simply that, boiled potatoes coarsely mashed and without a speck of salt, cream, butter, or any sense of care. They were lumpy and mealy, but were able to be coughed down with the aid of some gravy. The vegetables on the other hand, were beyond saving. A seasonal summer mix of corn, squash, and carrots that would typically be a delight, were instead a slimy mess of barely cooked produce that, like the potatoes, lacked any hint of salt or seasoning that could help mask the poor quality of the vegetables. Fresh? Frozen? I'd be amazed if they were anything but the latter. The highlight of most reviews was their homemade pies, but unfortunately after eating dinner here I could hardly stomach the thought of another bite at this location. If you're a restless cowboy on the brink of starvation you'll find a meal here, but I'd recommend moving along to any other watering hole here in Sheridan.
Always good food. I go once a week usually. Very personable staff. Sometimes a wait on the weekend, but worth it.
Excellent food 👍 I'd say skip the main course and go straight for the pie ... but the meatloaf was pretty darn good. Excellent food & good ppl , be patient if they're busy , the food won't disappoint.
Check out the menu! you won leave hungry here and the food is very good. Cute little cafe style place. They have sooo many homemade pie choices we’ll have to come back just for pie! They even have a pie sampler if you can’t decide. This is our second time eating here. It was busy . Megan serves and hostesses like a boss! She’s so on top of it! Great good, fabulous service, pleasant atmosphere. Pie and even beer. They make their own sangrias. Need anything more?
Lots of great choices, service is terrific, nice patio to enjoy the weather and people watch. The buffalo meatloaf is amazing!
Terrific coffee with quick refills. Omelet was very tasty. Efficient and friendly service. Wonderful homemade pie slices available. Visiting my son for an early mother's day treat. Surpassed my expectations.
I did not eat at the cafe but I did purchase a cherry and raspberry pie which was one of the best I’ve ever tasted. Absolutely amazing 🤩
We had several dishes and all were very good. The Chipolte patty melt was melt in your mouth good. Also had Avacado burger and open faced roast beef sandwich, all good. Try the peach mango white sangria, yum! They have so many choices of pies, but we didn't have room.
Very nice breakfast experience in a quaint western cafe. The food was good quality and well prepared, the room was comfortable and clean, and the staff was welcoming and very friendly and efficient.
My boyfriend and I stoped here while traveling, i got the urban grilled cheese with sweet potato friend and he got the outlaw burger i believe with regular fries, food was delicious and came out fast, I HIGHLY recommend the sweet potato fries they’re to die for! The waitress was also very kind, it is also in the cutest spot downtown so we also went and did a little shopping afterwards! 10/10 experience
Good food and excellent service. I went to have breakfast, it was really tasty, and the waitress was one if a kind, really helpful and joyful, also I order one their burgers for delivery, it was fresh and delicious. Totally would come again, next time we are in the area
Great food, reasonable portions, great atmosphere, and friendly servers. When I'm in Sheridan and hungry, this is one of my favorite spots.
Food is ok, service ok. We were asked to leave after our breakfast, seems they were having a large family come.
The chipotle patty melt (beyond burger as a vegetarian option), with Swiss cheese and sweet potatoes is great, the hot roast beef sandwich with mash potatoes is like ratatouille type of memory
Quick service, delicious burgers. My wife lived there fried cod.
Cowboy Cafe in Sheridan, Wyoming is a five-star restaurant! The Elk Sausage and Buffalo Sausage were amazing, the staff was kind and attentive, and the coffee was hot, delicious, and plentiful. Highly recommend!
If I could give zero I would. Worst French dip I've ever had. Ribs were super upsetting and the corn dog could have broke a window if I threw it. Absolutely do not recommend!!!! Service is terrible to. I told them of my experience with the food the previous time and they said I could Check my current food no apology or try to fix. Just terrible customer service! And current food looked edible but was sadly not..
The food was great the staff were amazing. It took a few minutes to get a table but hey, Good food and fantastic people are worth waiting on. Will be back next trip for sure. Thanks CC.
Great little Cafe in downtown Sheridan. We went on a Sunday morning and there was a wait line outside to get in. Staff did a great job flipping tables as quickly as possible while still providing great service and food. Definitely worth the wait. Another nice feature was that they served not only breakfast but lunch too given I have one member of my family that is not a breakfast fan.
Great flavors, fresh ingredients! Next time we'll save room for homemade pie.