Real Coffee Club
Coffee shopCoffee shop

Sagtown Coffee

★★★★☆ 4.4/5 (100 reviews)
$$
78 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 (631) 725-8696 Website
Sagtown Coffee Sagtown Coffee Sagtown Coffee Sagtown Coffee Sagtown Coffee

Reviews (100)

Jean Ng
Jean Ng
★★★★☆ Jan 20, 1970

Flat white is good but a little tad too hot. They have some cute shop merch.

Ruben C.Marines
Ruben C.Marines
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Cute little place for a delicious snack and a coffee. It has a clean and cozy sitting area. It may be pricey for some people since it is near the Hamptons area, but I really like it there. After having a nice snack and chat there, you can walk around the harbor in Sag.

jdnnschreiber
jdnnschreiber
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Very good coffee. Nice chill local place.

Matt Miller
Matt Miller
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

The black and tan is my go to!

NICK MENNELL
NICK MENNELL
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Loved the vibe of this place and the seasonal coffee (pumpkin spice) was delicious. The staff were friendly and although the wait Can take quite a while it seemed worth it.

Kenneth LeCointe
Kenneth LeCointe
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Had a fantastic Matcha Latte here. The place is very clean, and the interior seating makes good use of the space without seeming cramped. Well worth walking into town for on a fall day.

Evan
Evan
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Caramel Macchiato with oat milk was good! Kind of overpower with oats, not sure what type of oat milk they were using. The staff was cheerful and friendly, and they have lots of food options.

Joanna Salzman
Joanna Salzman
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Delicious coffee, yummy food, very clean, nice service. Get the breakfast burrito- full of veggies.

Ben Lechlitner
Ben Lechlitner
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Grabbed two sandwiches to go via online ordering and beat the lines. They were toasted to perfection and hit the spot as well carried on with the rest of the day. Only trouble around here is grabbing a parking spot along the main drag. I watched a 90 year old lady poach a spot from another patient driver. Savage.

Carol Zwielich
Carol Zwielich
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Great coffee served with great efficiency. I highly recommend this place. I have been there several times over the years and it never disappoints. Nice atmosphere, as well, with outdoor seating with umbrellas.

Tam Petersen
Tam Petersen
★★★★☆ Jan 20, 1970

Very first visit. My order was misplaced so I had to wait a while but it was rectified. My coffee was really delicious. I’ll definitely be back for an açai bowl!!

Mariah Moskowitz
Mariah Moskowitz
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Great drinks, good food, awesome people! The only place I go all year, almost everyday, 1-2 times a day. Love this crew!

FRANCESCA Acierno
FRANCESCA Acierno
★★★★☆ Jan 20, 1970

Great Coffee ☕️ 😋 But No Great Espresso 😞 The crew.....so so .....young people......different people.

Katie Love
Katie Love
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Staff are incredible!! Always super sweet and very clearly working hard :)

Barbara P
Barbara P
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

I am obsessed with the Acai Smoothie! Busy place. Great staff.

anita minong
anita minong
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Cozy place to have coffee in the morning.. the staff are nice too.

Carl Walker
Carl Walker
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

I had an excellent breve cortado, and some very good avocado toast. Cortado was proper temp and beans were smooth.

Kimberly Giang
Kimberly Giang
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Came here a couple of times for the matcha latte. Ordered pickup and it was ready quickly. My husband and I both enjoyed the quality of matcha with almond milk. Everything was consistently correct and staff was friendly. Would definitely recommend the matcha latte!

Larry Spielfogel
Larry Spielfogel
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

My favorite coffee breakfast place in Hamptons. Good food , avocado toast with egg, oatmeal, wraps all excellent, professional baristas and clean. S must go!

Kat Ames
Kat Ames
★★☆☆☆ Jan 20, 1970

Today is May 31st at 1pm. They have a total staff of 6 people. One to man the register, one at the coffee station, one juicer, two prep and 1 on cooking. I ordered a grilled cheese and a scoop of gelato. I waited 10min for the grilled cheese. Order after order came out and still no grilled cheese. The orders keep coming, and it’s getting busy. Finally I said to the barista I’m still missing the grilled cheese. Turns out they lost it. Honestly they had 1 food order before mine so how that happened is just ridiculous and of course by then they had a line out the door. The barista told the girl making the sandwich to hurry up and make it. The sandwich girl did not hurry and on top of that when the barista said (in Spanish) are you making the sandwich the girl said yes and then looked at the toaster and realized she forgot to turn it on. Then laughed. The food was for my father who takes medicine that requires he eat. To all this we got “sorry”. Work experience there ever.