Real Coffee Club
Coffee shopCoffee shop

Jack's Stir Brew Coffee

★★★★☆ 4.4/5 (22 reviews)
51 Division St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 (631) 808-3420 Website
Jack's Stir Brew Coffee Jack's Stir Brew Coffee Jack's Stir Brew Coffee Jack's Stir Brew Coffee Jack's Stir Brew Coffee

Reviews (22)

A
Arno
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

good

P
Patrick Williams
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Great coffee.

D
Dustin s
★☆☆☆☆ Jan 20, 1970

Have two spots to buy online never works are you even open

J
Jonathan Gordon
★★★☆☆ Jan 20, 1970

No hot food at this location. Only pastries. Website menu shows oatmeal. Brewed coffee was good. Smooth on the dark side with caramel notes. Basically, a take out shop.

F
FRANCESCA Acierno
★★☆☆☆ Jan 20, 1970

Nothing special

T
Taylor Snipes
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

I needed a cold brew with a kick to give me life after a classics too much fun in the Hamptons night and Jack’s delivered. It was strong, fresh, cold, and delicious. Oh and talk about plenty because this thing was big. I unfortunately did not have an appetite because #hungover but this cold brew brought me back to life. I’ll be back to try some of their vegan bakery items.

A
Andy Oberdier
★★★★★ Jan 19, 1970

Favorite place in sag for a cappuccino.

R
Richard Strother
★★★★★ Jan 19, 1970

Excellent coffees, nice vibe, pricey pastries but yummy

S
Sashene
★★★★★ Jan 19, 1970

Smooth, rich coffee and delectable pastries

S
Samuel Robins
★★★★★ Jan 19, 1970

E X C E L L E N T Hot Americano ! Recommended

M
Mariah M
★★★★☆ Jan 19, 1970

Overpriced but good.

P
Pinecross
★★★★★ Jan 19, 1970

I stopped at Jack's for the first time after a long drive and tougher than usual day. Delicious treats and my cappuccino was perfect. Thank you Veronica for your outstanding service and smile to turn my day around. I bought some coffee to serve at my airbnb and know the guests are going to love it!

A
Amy Welch-Olson
★★★★★ Jan 18, 1970

Really friendly and talented barista, great coffee/latte art

A
AlbertaSpruce
★★★★★ Jan 18, 1970

Matcha latte with oat milk , and lots of vegan and organic treats. Yum !

J
Jay Lankau
★★★★☆ Jan 18, 1970

So cute on the inside, with a very friendly staff. Great cold brew and other coffee, though it is on the expensive side if you aren't used to Sag Harbor prices.

M
Maral M
★★★★★ Jan 18, 1970

Delicious coffee, specialty lattes, and lovely baristas

T
Tom
★★☆☆☆ Jan 18, 1970

Jack's coffee is consistently sour by all objective measures. (Tried it twice in 6 months.) Mentioned the sour taste to the person working there and got the polite reply, "no it's not". But, yes, it is. If you don't mind sour coffee, Jack's is the place. If you don't, save your money. The pastries are good, but if not to your liking, the bakery next door is great . . . . and so is their coffee.

A
Alecia Moore
★★★★★ Jan 18, 1970

Has options for all dietary restrictions and has amazing coffee that is way vetter than Hampton coffee company or starbucks

D
Devon Jeffers
★★★★★ Jan 18, 1970

Great service. The vanilla Latte is awesome.

T
Tom Sheehan
★★★★★ Jan 18, 1970

Get the Jack's Coffee Thermos. I bought a hot coffee this morning at 8:15 and it is now 1:30 and the coffee is still warm. Granted it's not the freshest brew, but that's my fault! Go get this thermos.... And Jack's is a great coffee shop as well... : )