Reviews (100)
I am so thankful for afforable, DELICIOUS food! Love this place! Great service, great food, great prices!
We really enjoyed our meal here. The service was wonderful. Employees were very patient and helpful. I had a small meat pizza and hubby had Reuben. The couple with us had sandwiches. Everything was delicious. The baked goods were all so good, too. We had snickerdoodle cookies and bought cinnamon rolls to go. My only regret is that we don't live closer and can't eat here all the time. Don't miss this wonderful place!!
So worth the wait if you're driving east or west on highway 20 thru Nebraska. The pizza, the sandwiches, the breakfast... unmatched! Do yourself a favor and stop here for a meal!
There's nothing bad to say about Old Mill. Very good food. Great quality products and the friendliest staff in town. The clientele, like anywhere, can be extremely rude and self-centered. That's not Old Mill's fault. It has more to do with location. Stop by, though. It's an experience that should be had by everyone passing through.
Best Sandwiches 5 star 🌟 PIZZA rater by a 12 year old Best Customer service Atmosphere TOP notch!
BEST FOOD IN NEBRASKA This is my second time visiting the Old Mill and once again my taste buds are still relishing the incredible food I devoured over 30min ago. My Husband and I moved from Arizona to NE, last spring, and this is by far the BEST spot to grab a bite. The menu has an array of options from pizza to deli meat sandwiches. However, the #14 wrap is hands down worth the 55 minute drive! It's loaded with freshly cut chicken deli meat, bacon, onion, jalapenos and a sweet-spicy cream cheese spread that will make your belly full and your taste buds screaming for more. If you're ever going through, or live nearby Valentine, then be sure to stop in and give it a try; and don't worry if the parking lot looks full you won't wait long. They have an excellent system to get the orders out quick without sacrificing the quality. Besides, you can always take a gander at the store side and leave with either trinkets, spices, cookies, deli meat and cheeses to go, farm fresh eggs, or hamburger as well as buffalo ground meat.
Sandwiches (the Classic!) and pizza were delicious. Fresh ingredients, crazy- large portions and great prices. Can't recommend this place enough! Want to come back and try their bakery items. Cookies looked massive!
New address they are now in the old movie theatre building. Excellent sandwiches, they bake most of their own bread, great selection of bulk foods to choose from! Popcorn,other crunchy snacks, candy, chocolate, jelly, Amish butter among other things. They are still getting on there feet after the fire,but this area is so glad to have them open again.wonderful people.
This place is amazing. Definitely worth a visit. I ordered a sandwich and I cannot adequately explain how delicious it was. The blend of meats, cheeses, and flavors was amazing. I have never liked pickles, but the way they added to the rest of the flavors made for the first time I have ever enjoyed them. Quality ingredients throughout makes a difference. The deli has shelf after shelf of unique food items. We ended up purchasing over $250 worth of goods including Amish popcorn, real molasses, pure horseradish, after-dinner mints, chocolate coins, garlic seasoning, bulk dried marshmallows (ala Lucky Charms), homemade cookies (3 varieties) and much more. We were tempted by much more than we purchased. I am so glad that we stopped in.
This is such a cool shop! It's tucked out of the way in Valentine, so if you don't know it's there, you might miss it. But you should not miss it! The sandwiches are very tasty, and I haven't tried the pizza but I will be back. The gift shop area has cute things. A treasure hidden in the sandhills.
Wow!! The caramel apple pecan cinnamon roll gets a 10/10. I have never had a cinnamon roll that good, and I will never be satisfied will any cinnamon roll after having this one from the Old Mill. I hope they have them the next time I come!! Excited for the coffee shop to open. The storefront is very unique and the sandwich I had was good. The Italian, I believe. I did feel like the sandwiches were a little expensive. The staff is very, very friendly though and you can't beat that! Update: coffee shop is open!!!! Love love loved my mocha latte and my caramel pecan rolls. 🤤 I just love this place.
We were driving from Nebraska to the Black Hills and stopped at Valentine for a quick lunch. This place has good sandwiches and pizzas. I personally don't eat sandwiches, but I took a bite of my husband's sandwich and it was yummy. The other side sell coffee and desserts. It was good as well.
Their rueben was Delicious. Cooked to perfection. Would definitely refer this place, they also have a variety of food to eat, chips, jerky etc 😋
Very modern. Staff are nice and the wait is not long. The food is amazing. Personally, I recommend the California wrap.
We enjoyed incredible sandwiches!!
Best cookies we've ever had. Traveled from Michigan just to get Monster cookies. The best part "we found out they ship the cookies"!!!!! Unlimited supply of Monster cookies in our future.
Awesome selection of dried goods, and the pizza is fantastic.
Thank you so much for 'making it right' when my pizza was burnt. The cheeseburger bacon pizza is so yummy..... Love the pickles.... Think I need my own jar, there wasn't enough of them. 😋😂
This was my first time at Old Mill but won't be my last. Great food and baked items
An absolute surprise find on our road trip - doesn't look like much from the outside, but the inside was amazingly crafted, the sandwiches were great and there was a lot to browse while waiting for the fresh food to be made. (Check their bulk candy!)