Reviews (100)
We stop here for a bite and a beer every trip down. Always a great experience!!
Best pizza I have ever had in my entire life. the experience was as a dream. 10 out of 10 recommended.
The atmosphere is really welcoming and the outdoor seating has a great view. I drove down from North Miami in hopes of enjoying a gluten free pizza before heading down to key west but unfortunately the cauliflower crust came out as having gluten. I ordered a pepperoni and a meat lovers pizza and both had gluten, I’m not sure if the toppings had gluten or the crust itself or if it was cross contamination. If you have severe celiac like I do please be careful.
What a GEM. DELICIOUS food. Everything was phenomenal. Grouper Rueben is a must! If you do not stop and enjoy a meal, you are missing out. We actually stopped enroute to the airport and grabbed our last meal to take to the airport. It's SOOOO GOOD!!
We found this place on our way home from Key West. I just googled “Key Lime Pie” on google maps and chose the highest rated place. You can’t imagine how surprised we were, when discovered that they have a dogs menu!!! Our puppy was so happy! He had chicken and rice. I think that every dog friendly restaurant should have something like that ❤️ Lobster bisque was great! 🦞 Hawaiian pizza had a lot of pineapples 🍍 as we love it! And key lime pie was a winner for sure! Next time when we are visiting keys, this place is on a list for a lunch stop!
Good food but would have preferred to eat in person rather than delivering for sure. I ordered the tavernier sand which and the veggie pizza with pepperoni. In the morning, got a nitro hazelnut coffee and a cuban coffee. $10 minimum on cards and free delivery!
I have loved this place forever. Being a former resident fell in love with the charm of this fun Islamorada gem with a late 70's/80's flair with a few olds school video games and vintage memorabilia. Jacqueline the owner is very sweet. Everything is delicious but my fave dish is the Michael Angelo tortellini (in the creamy sauce with prosciutto and crispy bread) and the Carrot cake is the best I have ever had and I have eaten a lot of 🥕 🎂 ! They are connected to the Paddle board shop 'Otherside' which is also a great little clothing store and paddle board resource. Kudos to the entire team at Bayside Gourmet and Otherside Paddle shop 🤗💯🤩A must stop location everytime we get back down to the Keys! 😁
Excellent food, friendly service. Can be a bit loud inside but has a nice outside option. Best Chicken Parm there is...
Always love coming here. I've tried tons of their dishes and I have yet to find soenthing that I didn't like. Their pasta dish portions are absolutely huge and are so flavorful. Always worth it. Their pizza is crisp, thin crusted. Service is always fabulous. Inside and outside dinning avaliable. Inside is always nice and cold. Great way to cool off.
NOT KID FRIENDLY. if you are a family with small children who require a high chair this place is not for you. They only have one and it was in use while we were there. The servers were not happy we had kids with us and made us feel super uncomfortable so we ate and ran. However, with that being said.. food was delicious and service was quick. (Maybe because they wanted us gone lol)
Just got down to the Keys and we selected Bayside Gourmet due to the high ratings...thankfully the ratings are spot on! Service was excellent. Our server knew the menu and made some good suggestions. My wife had the lobster bisque and it was creamy and flavorful. She also had the gourmet salad - greens, pecans, pears, bacon, and Bleu cheese. Nothing was left...so I know she enjoyed it! I had a four cheese pizza with prosciutto and spinach. Crust was firm, but not chewy and the ingredients were obviously fresh. Lastly, the price was very reasonable. Highly recommended!
Wow, wow, wow! What a cool joint with amazing food. Smoked Fish Dip, Pizza, Meatballs, were all delicious. Wow...did I already say Wow? I'm so happy we came here. Oh, and Dragon's Lair!
The staff is friendly and they make the best key lime pie that i have ever had in the keys. They have a few retro arcade games in the front to play.
Used to be my favprite place in medicine hat, just ordered my usual "oink oink poutine" and got a tiny little thing of pulled pork( not even a quarter of what they used to give you & same with the gravy). Also the food was soggy and cold . Sad that my favorite resturaunt took such a dive , i will not be ordering from here anymore .
Just finished a large works pizza from this restaurant, absolutely the the best pizza we have ever eaten, and I’m 62 years old! Very tasty and no skimping in toppings! Thank You Very Much. You need to try their pizza. Tomorrow I will go there for a dinner!!!
The baked cavateli was awesome, I assume the pasta is all great if they use the same sauce. Avoid the Phili Sandwich...its not the real deal...stick with the pasta.
No ocean view but the outside seating is very quiet and shady. The service is great. I highly recommend the grouper ruben.
Excellent pizza and the wait staff are super friendly and attentive. I can not wait to come back again...plus, they have free arcade games while you wait which is a nice touch!!
Live pong, bunch of free arcade machines, delicious food. Will be back again.
Ohh the pizza is amazing!! The service is top notch. The ambience is 80s/90s. You will have a great time.