Reviews (100)
Some of the most amazing pizza I’ve ever had! Traveled up here from Littleton for a getaway, and I wish there was a location closer to home. We went two days in a row to try some menu items, the crack fries are the best! Our servers were Shaye and Bones, both fantastic, friendly and outgoing, really made the experience even more out of this world. Amazing vibe from the whole place, and top notch service as well!
🥹😃I’m not sure words can accurately describe what you experience when you come to The Secret Stash… the vibe, the food, it’s all beyond incredible! I’d highly recommend stopping in here, no matter where you’re from! Absolutely delicious in every way possible.
My kids and I come here every year and we’ve never had a bad experience. The last time was especially perfect, we come in and get greeted by an amazing hostess, they swiftly seat us at a great table by the windows and our server (JoJo) come and greets us with a big smile. the food arrived very quickly and in order, rather than having the appetizers arrive after the pizza. We finish our pizza and leave, but not without a friendly “thanks for coming in”. 10/10 would recommend.
Groovy little pizza shop in DT Crested Butte. Been around over a decade. Menu has been streamlined but there are still great combos to be had. We had the Notorious FIG with a side of arugula. Claim to have the best margarita in town but I hope that's not true🥺 . Friendly owner, manager and servers. Definitely a must do when in CB.
You can never go wrong at the Stash. Must try are their mozzarella sticks and the Notorious F.I.G. pizza. Super friendly and fast service.
Wonderful place, everyone working there was friendly and the food was awesome. Thank God they had draft beer because during the off season there's nothing open in this town and I like to try the local brews. Don't bother going anywhere else in these town.....this place is all you need.
Live here, the only place I get pizza. Great service. Love the staff. They give back to the community school in a big way. The owner is peaceful and cares about the employees. They are always nice to my kids too. The other pizza place is aggressive and it isn’t the same quality.
I'm just so happy they exist. I've just had so much pizza in Denver just hoping it would be different (good) and it's just not that great, regardless of the price point and the painful amount of options. I know there's a few good ones, and i don't negate the fact, but I'm still so incredibly happy that Secret Stash, along with a few other small mountain town pizzerias throughout Colorado are here, and have been putting in so much work and heart into making something that actually brings unmitigated joy when a patron is sitting down and taking a bite... Just go check it out. It's a full-on, un-ignorable statement when I can't leave without making sure the crusts are gone too. You won't either when they're just as good as the rest of the pie.
Love this place- fun bar with nice selections, very friendly service and REALLY good pizza! Highly highly recommend the Hamptons- wow- that lemon pepper crust is insane! I love pizza with arugula and prosciutto and this is by far the very best… Look forward to visiting again soon!
Cool place, a little over decorated for me, but that’s completely personal. The music was good, waiter was very nice and the pizza was incredible. A LOT OF VEGAN OPTIONS, including cheeses and proteins available which is the best! I missed having such a great pizza with fresh ingredients.
Great food, great service, cold beer and a fun atmosphere...what more is needed? Try the Buddha Belly pizza, it's better than it sounds. Add some crack fries and a 90 and I think that would make most people's night!
This pizza place is amazing! I’m vegan so I loved the vegan pizza I brought it home to freeze and treasure I haven’t found anything like this. My family love the wings, and traditional pizza. The ambiance is amazing, service you won’t regret it!
First time and absolutely loved it. Pizza was legendary. But do yourself a favor and get the crack fried with the pie. You'll thank me later.
Can’t tell for sure why we love this place, but it just works for the family. Great food, great service, funky atmosphere that stands out. It’s just a joy to experience when we are in town. Thank you!
The Secret Stash is one of the most incredible pizzeria experiences one should experience in one’s life time and having lived in Napoli, Italy this is really a fantastic statement to make! What a place and what a find!! Upon doing a little more snooping afterwards on the owner of this establishment it all makes sense in a way. Thankfulness and gratitude and practicing this upon her staff with 1k tip for the kitchen staff and the Secret Stash Matches the donation given? Goes a long way, and lemme tell you folks…many a 1k HAVE been given! Kyleena Falzone probably did 80 plus pizza crusts while my husband and I sat in awe and amazement, whilst watching her bustling crew of 30 plus staff move and groove around the hundreds of hungry skiers waiting patiently for some tasty, uniquely thought out culinary perfections! You can see Kyleena in some of my photos (after I asked her if she minded if I posted her of course) and we chatted about her 90 plus countries she visited and her latest travels to Ireland. Loved this girl who was the same age as I, with similar passions, and same attitudes when it came to conquering health battles and rising to the top vs. letting health issues stop us from being the shooting stars that we are :’) Lastly? I knew I found the most truly special restaurant when the man sitting next to me asked what the Wi-Fi password was…. #trytalkingtoyourfamily
Got Three pizzas to go. Walked over about the time we were told they would be ready. There was some issue that caused about another half hour delay. That said, the pizzas were very good and were devoured quickly when we got back. The atmosphere was crazy and fun, like a Buddhist, boozy disco party. It would have been fun to eat there if we could have. Expect busyness and wait times just like anywhere else.
Great atmosphere, pizza and drinks! We got the Notorious FIG pizza and loved it- unique and something we never would have thought to order but was recommended by our server. It was wonderful!
Incredible pizza with a funky vibe. It’s on our must stop list every time we are in Crested Butte. Make sure you get a bit of flavor on the crust (we prefer salt and pepper.)
This place is great! Friendly staff great decor and wonderful pizzas!! Shay and Sue our bartender ma were so lovely.
I hear this is really good. Can’t wait to go here when I visit in February. Update: I had lunch here yesterday and it did not disappoint... We had the Notorious F.I.G. and the You’re Driving Me Caprese with Crack Fries and a hazy IPA. Quite simply the best pizza I’ve ever had!