Postmasters Coffee and Bakery

1,000 STARS! This is the best coffee shop in PA. Incredible vibe, quality, and staff. I went to their Grand Opening and was thoroughly impressed. I love that this shop was a dream come true for a pair of sisters - who are absolutely lovely and beyond talented.
The coffee is super yummy and high end.
The pastries from the bakery are top notch - with every bite being a delight.
I love the effort put into the decor and subtle art. Especially the bathroom. The hand painted art in the bathroom is incredible and pleasing to the eye. I love when businesses invest in their bathroom aesthetic and cleanliness.
Do yourself a favor and check it all out.

My wife and I come in at least once a week. Consistently the best coffee I've ever had. The sisters also make all the pastries; and everything from the morning buns to the quiche are amazing. It's a nice touch that they have recognized our faces, and I hope they don't get tired of em, because we won't stop coming to Postmasters!

There should be a postmasters in every city. Pastries and food items…. So freaking delicious. It’s obvious no corners are cut with their recipes. Everything I’ve ordered has been better than “mom used to make.” From go-to chocolate chip cookies to creative savory items, never disappointed.
Coffee is perfect. People are friendly.

So I have been wanting to stop in and check out this new place. Today my mom and I went to get something warm to drink. Pulled in parking lot and a very friendly welcoming lady came out and said I am sorry but we are closed. But she graciously offered us a Chia tea. Regardless. While she went in to get our drinks I checked time, they closed at 2:00 and it was 2:44. She not only brought our drinks out to us almost 45 minutes after they closed but she said “no charge just come back when we are open to try us out” Am definitely going back. Please check them out and enjoy the very friendly staff. 😊

I'm writing this review after my first experience at Postmasters. First impressions are strong!! The decor (especially the Christmas decorations) is beautiful - tasteful and elegant, but still welcoming. The staff was knowledgeable, friendly, and the right amount of conversational. The latte was delicious and perfectly made (I asked for it to be lightly sweetened with their vanilla brown sugar syrup, and the guy nailed it. So many places make drinks too sweet, even when asked to cut back the syrup, and this was just perfect).
I was in a hurry, so I didn't get to try any of the pastries, but they looked wonderful. I can't wait to go back and test more stuff out!

So glad to see Waynesboro bringing in quality like this! I wish Smithsburg would follow suit!

High quality coffee and pastries - quality decor, quality service. I can’t believe they are in waynesboro tbh.

Delicious!! Wow oh wow, I was shocked by such a beautiful, trendy spot in Waynesboro. Worked in Philly for four years, and the quality of the coffee and baked goods could compete handsomely in the city. It has the warmth, down to hearth, and prices of a small town. Such a treasure, will definitely become a regular haunt for me and my family.

Delicious! I got an expertly made Matcha Latte with a peach blueberry crostada and a bacon drop biscuit. I enjoyed every bit of it! The biscuit was my favorite part! It was crumbly perfectly moist, savory, and full of bacon and onions. All I need now is for them to serve eggs and I’ll never go anywhere else for breakfast, especially since their menu changes daily. Their donuts are amazing and so is their coffee shop!

Some of the best coffee I've ever had, easily. Not to mention I've met with the owners on multiple occasions at the farmer's market in town and feel a personal connection with them and hence feel more comfortable being there. Definitely recommend!

This place should appear on a Google search for coffee near me, but it didn't the last time I looked.
I like the ambience. The coffee is fine, with some flavor syrups available that are not found elsewhere. The one pastry I got was excellent; I'm eager to try others.