Erie Island Coffee Co.

Coffee and food are great. Dining area was clean. Staff was awesome. Prices are reasonable. Bathroom could've been cleaner. But overall it's probably my new favorite place in downtown Elyria.

Good coffee and place to talk. It was cold inside there though.

I'm a new customer. Just stopped in to take out some breakfast. The Hammy sandwich is fantastic!! I would highly recommend!!

Great atmosphere and very friendly staff. Autumn was very kind and efficient. The food is good too!

Coffee-delicious! Staff-warm and welcoming! Clean, inviting and all-around delightful. We will be back!!

The old Donna's Diner has been nicely remodeled into a modern coffee shop. It has an open, minimalist feel to it, but it's not noisy and the chairs are comfortable and solid. The coffee was excellent, and available in enough variety to satisfy anyone. There is a small selection of baked goods, and a limited menu of sandwiches, many with unusual ingredients. Looked to be worth exploring over time, though. And the servers were polite and efficient; obviously have been well-trained, which is a welcome touch in a new establishment. All in all, the place is off to a good start, and well worth a number of return visits.

To notch customer service! Excellent coffee! The wedding soup was kinda blah though no real flavor. Everything else was very good

Cute, modern decor, unique drinks and sandwiches. Friendly staff, reasonable prices. Seats are wood. Not a place to dawdle over breakfast or lunch

Omg this place blew my mind. The coffee was excellent but the food was even better. The SOB was delicious and so was the Italian sandwich. I will definitely be back.

Food was really good. Decor is great. Would have given 5 stars if the waitress had not forgotten my drink. Almost finished my sandwich and was wondering why no drink. She got distracted and forgot while talking to fellow worker. But she was nice about it and brought me a larger drink that was ordered. All in all a lovely establishment.