Fayetteville Bakery & Cafe

I was leaving a home tour early one morning, and I remembered, I haven’t had my coffee yet. I decided to stop at this nearby shop. There was plenty of parking available. I went inside and enjoyed the space. Plenty of seating and appealing to the eye. I even noticed a speaker and wondered what that might be used for. The gentleman at the counter was very friendly and had a very pleasant demeanor and conversation. He expressed everything is naturally sourced and ethically sound, which was nice to know. He also invited me to come back on a Tuesday night, because they do family friendly Karaoke. I’m sure when it’s busier, he wouldn’t have all the time in the world to chat, but with each customer, I noticed he gave focused service.
I appreciate that. Give them a try! Great service, good egg bites, and nice coffee.

I totally loved the environment. Beautiful, relaxing, clean. It's lovely. Truly. Sweet barista helped me decide on SGM coffee and I bought a giant oatmeal raisin that was gf, a slice of white cake and a pumpkin cinnamon roll. I sat and enjoyed the lovely shop and drank my coffee and ate the cookie. I can unequivocally say the cookie was amazing!! Especially shocking because it was gf and I usually have come to know that it means not tasty. I was so wrong. It was wonderful. I just now had a couple bites of cake that I took home to share. It was fairly dry and pretty dense. I'm wondering if slicing and putting them in plastic storage exposes it to air. Just a thought. The cinnamon roll was similar. Not moist. Now I'm sad because I love sweets. ☹️. My husband took a bite and didn't want to eat it after that initial taste and passed on trying the cinnamon roll.

The family who owns this place is so sweet! I wanted a cake and smash cake for my son's first birthday. She was SO helpful and the cakes turned out amazing! Come to find out, their 10 year old helped make all the bees for the cake and the dad jumped in to help assemble them. I thought that was SO neat and I loved that their daughter helped with the cake. It was rich and moist, the cakes were beautifully done and they couldn't have been nicer! I would highly recommend this place to anyone. They also have lots of pastries, coffee, etc. and the space is really nice! It'd be a great place to just sit and relax with coffee and a book or to meet up with friends.

Fayetteville Bakery and Cafe does its name justice! One of the best representations of our town. From the artwork displayed, to the drink names, and the owner’s knowledge and love for this town. Franco and Tiffany are both very welcoming, friendly, and hardworking. The pastries are delicious and freshly made, so much they fly off the shelf! Their humming bird cake and cinnamon rolls are very popular. Cookies, bagels, cakes…kolaches! Being from Texas, Kolaches were a pleasant surprise. Both savory and sweet options.
The coffee is so good! Franco introduced me to Death wish and made me the only pumpkin spice coffee I’ve actually enjoyed. His military and Fayetteville themed inspired drinks are all delicious.
The shop advertises local events and both Tiffany and Franco are very involved in the community. You can’t step foot in the shop and not feel part of a tight knit group!
There’s a growing library and Franco is full of great Fayetteville history. Tiffany is a joy to talk to about her cooking, family, and work in our community.
Tiffany’s cakes make to order are an absolute gem. From mermaid cakes to Declaration of Independence decorations, I’ve seen people leave in awe of her creations. And from how well her pastries taste, easy to know her cakes are just as good!
Oh! And every Saturday, Franco offers conceal carry classes! His Tv displays more information on the shop events as well as local events. Great place to get plugged in!

Miss Tiffany is a great supporter of the arts. They have great food that is baked in house. They have coffee, tea and other hot drinks. They also have great smoothies.
On the arts, the business is a great supportive environment. They display and sell in consignment art from individual artists that they know. They host one of the two free, family friendly open mics in the Fayetteville area. They hosted "Artists 4 Autism Awareness" in April 2022.
The food is great, the atmosphere relaxed and the service is a-one. Please do not hesitate to stop in for yourself. They have outlets for your electronics , as well as wifi for their customers.

I have not had a chance to try their food but my ice latte was outstanding. And I love that they have the cozi section for the couches and chairs they even have the opportunity to get a book but you have to bring it back boy do I love to read. Can't wait to make this my new favorite spot

I called last minute wanting a custom made spice cake in 3 days. Tiffany accepted the challenge. I was really expecting something similar to a sheet cake from Walmart. However Fayetteville bakery showed up and showed out. Tiffany delivered everything I wanted and more. The birthday boy was completely over the moon with his cake. Wonderful service.

3 stars for having good customer service, clean facility, great location! The cake looked good but wasn’t, my daughter who loves sweets didn’t like it… my coffee Carmel macchiato started to taste funny at the 1/2 mark so when I got home (7mins from the shop) I looked inside and was disgusted! Threw the rest of the cake and coffee away! I love trying different coffee shops, but this one I won’t be returning to!

I'm not sure which was better, the cinnamon roll or the service!!!!! Tiffany is amazing and so sweet. She warmed up my delicious cinnamon roll and made me the best latte ever!!!!!!! My new favorite cafe ❤️

Excellent service. For those who like coffee with flavor, I would recommend Signatures coffee Rocko and Southern Praline with a shot of Death wish coffee.