Ithaca Coffee Company

What a fabulous place! Really excellent coffee and coffee drinks, terrific food and that market! There's a huge variety of fresh cheeses, packages of high quality snack foods from gourmet crackers to truffle popcorn, local products and chocolates. On top of that, the staff is incredibly nice! Just wish I lived closer...

This review cannot possibly do justice to all the Ithaca Coffee Company has to offer, but they make great coffee drinks and sandwiches (The Cubano is my favorite!). They have an incredible selection of local foods and an amazing assortment of cheeses. They have a wide selection of local and non-local beers. I've only scratched the surface here, but you could spend a half day browsing all of the wonderful offerings in the Ithaca Coffee Company and still not see everything. I love the fact that almost hidden in the back is a quiet dining area where you can hang out and get some work done while enjoying a vanilla latte and a blueberry muffin. The Ithaca Coffee Company is one of my favorite places to hang out.

Behind the random strip mall exterior is a wonderful experience! Barista recommended London Fog oat milk tea. Wow! clearly made from their own organic blend and the best I’ve ever tasted. Breakfast sandos made to order are amazing and the large space includes a tavern w/beers to-go too. Gourmet local food and an impressive cheese selection also here. Love Ithaca Coffee Company 💜

Food and coffe are excellent but services should improved. I asked for reward program, staff gave me the card without explaining that my order didn't added in the program, yet. When I checked my ORDER HISTORY and found out that it wrote..You haven't placed any orders yet. That made me very upset.

Took forever! Like well over half an hour and there were only 2 other people in the whole place. After we ate, I asked the 'chef' if they sold the horseradish in a jar that was on the Cuban sandwich. He said they don't put horseradish on the Cuban. We laughed so hard. Oh... there was definitely horseradish. It burned our sinuses out in a great way. So well that i really wanted to buy a jar. Lol! I have a feeling it was the mustard that has horseradish in it. Maybe new cooks due to college break? The food was tasty at least.

I bought a bag of whole bean Ethiopia Yirgacheffe and it was the worst Yirgacheffe I have ever tried. Either the coffee was stored for too long before or the processing method couldn't make the flavor come out or the beans were just bad. Do not buy their Yirgacheffe because you always have a better choice elsewhere.

First time visit I found all of the shopping fun. Food delicious! However, I went to order a coffee and one of the employees seemed shockingly rude to me. They seemed polite to other people. I just can't see why me.

We were in Ithaca for a long weekend in February 2021 and we stumbled upon Ithaca Coffee Company as our AirBnB had the coffee available for guests to have. After having a cup in the morning, we decided we needed to make a stop at the store. AMAZING store and even better coffee! We bought multiple cans to give as gifts to our dog sitters. We were able to find some snacks for our weekend, there are kitchen supplies, trinkets, a café, and even a small tavern! Such a cool place. The employees were super friendly and welcoming. This will always be a stop on our list when in the Ithaca area!

Great quality coffee and nice place to hang out! Highly recommend over Starbucks

Love, love and more love this place! When in Town, I always try and hit up Ithaca Coffee Co.; now, it’s permanently moved to a plaza on outskirts of Town, but worth the 2 minutes extra drive. Parking is ample. Product selection is select down to the minutest detail items, for example, was able to find orange bitters as well as Dutch licorice. The cheese selection is varied and is an astute selection. Beth, was very kind and outfitted me with a frequent shoppers card prior to my modest but noteworthy purchase of hard-to-find grocery items to take back with me to Buffalo, New York, in my car cooler... do it and just be happy you did it! Will return and also shop online, the coffee beans are to die for!!!