Geneva Gelato

Amazing Gelato! Recently studied abroad in Rome and this is probably the closest thing I’ve had to authentic Italian gelato in the states! Both classic and creative flavors. Service was only reason for 4 stars and not 5 although we still received our order relatively quickly. Definitely recommend!

Great atmosphere, tons of treats to satisfy the sweet tooth on top of the many gelato flavors, great coffee, great tea, fun location and very friendly staff!👍👍

Very friendly owner. Variety to choose from. Never had Gelato before so I was pleasantly surprised how yummy it was. I tried the salted caramel which was good. But my son had a watermelon and some purple one and it was so good. Highly recommend!

We were looking forward to visiting this ice cream shop, but unfortunately left unimpressed. I don't get the sense that it's actual gelato since it didn't have the same creamy flavor and texture. There were a lot of ice chips still in mine. I must be missing something based on all of the glowing reviews.

Lovely little place downtown! Amazing coffee and gelato. We tried the affogato (gelato and espresso) and it was delicious! Highly recommend trying that if it’s your first time here, and if you like coffee. Probably the best place for coffee in Geneva!

It is a real treat to have a place like this in a small town like Geneva. All flavors are homemade and delicious. There are also some special treats they stock from Cheesy Eddie's in Rochester - I always bring home a slice!
The owner is dedicated and hard-working. It is not easy to stay afloat as a small business here but Jeff gives it his all. I am grateful to have Geneva Gelato in our downtown and will support them as much as I can - and I always recommend as a place to go!

I don't know why I waited so long to come here! The gelato and my cappuccino was great!!

The Gelato was exceptional as was the service... Jeff is such a great guy, knows his product well, and obviously enjoys what he's doing... which makes the Gelato taste even better than it already does. Always a satisfyingly good experience. LOVE Geneva Gelato... ❤

The gelato is absolutely delicious! Expect to pay a little more than you would at a typical ice cream shop, but it's well worth it. They always have a great selection of intriguing and exciting flavors, as well as comforting standbys (including a deeply rich chocolate).

This was my first trip to Geneva Gelato. It was a wonderful experience. I had the Chocolate Chewy Brownie gelato. It was delicious! My husband had the Peanutbutter crunch. He said it was like a reese's pieces flurry but better. The owner was very friendly. I would highly recommend this place.