Old Mill Bulk Foods & Deli

Thank you so much for 'making it right' when my pizza was burnt. The cheeseburger bacon pizza is so yummy..... Love the pickles.... Think I need my own jar, there wasn't enough of them. 😋😂

Wow!! The caramel apple pecan cinnamon roll gets a 10/10. I have never had a cinnamon roll that good, and I will never be satisfied will any cinnamon roll after having this one from the Old Mill. I hope they have them the next time I come!! Excited for the coffee shop to open. The storefront is very unique and the sandwich I had was good. The Italian, I believe. I did feel like the sandwiches were a little expensive. The staff is very, very friendly though and you can't beat that!

Update: coffee shop is open!!!! Love love loved my mocha latte and my caramel pecan rolls. 🤤 I just love this place.

Great place to get the cheese! I got Carolina reaper cheddar! And a good sandwich!

I am so thankful for afforable, DELICIOUS food! Love this place! Great service, great food, great prices!

Best Sandwiches
5 star 🌟 PIZZA rater by a 12 year old
Best Customer service
Atmosphere TOP notch!

I like finding a local place to eat, rather than just a fast food place that all tastes the same. Well, this one is on a must have list! Sandwiches are amazing. (I haven't tried the pizza, yet) I've had a different kind of sandwich, every time I've gone, and there are none on an "avoid list". Very delicious, and way fancier than Subway. They also have shelves, with various dried fruits and nuts, and candy. Fancy cheeses... Also, a bakery, and shelves of mugs and various knick knacks. I recommend this place to any coworkers who come through, and every time they've liked it too.

Stopped here for lunch on our road trip! We got sandwiches and pizza. The cheesy BLT was a hit. They are very generous with pizza toppings — they say it feeds 2-3 people, and it might even feed 4 if you buy a baked good for dessert. The bathrooms were clean too!

Oh my goodness! What a fun place to visit. Lots of fun bulk items such as candies and fudge as well as noodles and seasonings. We stopped for a quick bite before the wrestling meet we came to town for. We were expecting the usual sandwich place but these sandwiches were fantastic! I had the #1 with the special homemade sauce and my husband had the Italian sandwich. Absolutely delicious! We are going to take my parents there tomorrow.

Well I don't like being the first for a bad review, but my experience wasn't very positive. First I walked up to the counter and three people, one who appeared to be either an owner or manager, walked away. One young gal finally came and took my order and she seemed new or confused. It was just one of their normal sandwiches off the board. Well, after waiting for 25 minutes and having four other people who came in after me get their orders, I just left. Maybe they were just having a bad day, I will have to try again next time I am in town.

Amazing find. Traveling through Valentine we stopped for lunch at Old Mill, not knowing what to expect. We found an incredible menu of pizzas, wraps and sandwiches with high end ingredients at a fair price. We had the Tuscan sandwich, Greek wrap, Old Mill special sandwich and chicken salad sandwich. We all raved about our meals. The toppings and condiments were perfectly paired with great meats. Then we purchased some bakery items which were phenomenal. Then bought several "bulk containers" including salted caramel chocolates, dates, gluten free noodles, etc. Did I mention the decor is very nice, too, with lots of room and an open kitchen? The only downfall was that we wouldn't be able to stay to try their pizza. It looked delicious. This place would be a star in any city. In a small town it's truly amazing.