Search

Amenities

  • Wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Outdoor seating
  • Takeaway
  • Dine-in

Lighthouse Keeper's Pantry Reviews - 71

4.8
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Caroline Kiehnau

I love this cafe! The food is great and super cute for pictures or just meeting up with friends. The Cape aesthetic all throughout the store is perfect to bring friends visiting the Cape or for locals to get their regular coffees with the super friendly baristas!

Joo Young Lim

Stopped here because I love their Instagram account and it was so beautiful. I met the owner: so welcoming and with so much great knowledge of the town. The cold brew was the best I’ve ever had, the music was great and the food was even better. Must visit for sure.

Christina Jones

Best coffee on the mid-cape! Super convenient location right on 6A in Yarmouth Port. It opened last fall and has been such a great addition to the neighborhood. The cutest little café with great local products and delicious baked goods. The ham and cheese croissant, maple scone, and lemon poppy seed muffins are all unreal. And you absolutely have to try the cranberry hot-sauce, yum.

Kieran Nunan

Wonderful coffee, pastries, and the best breakfast sandwiches on the Cape. Also a fun place to shop for high quality jams, hot sauces, food items and housewares. This cafe is an awesome addition to Yarmouth Port!

Roland Poirier

Coffee a little on strong side. I had coffee cake. Very good. My wife had a scone - didn't taste fresh when compared to one she had 4 days earlier. Prices are a bit high, but quality and cleanliness were very good. For the price, items must be fresh. Will definitely give it another try.

Katie Murphy

Delight abounds in this charming gourmet local food shop and cafe! For starters, it’s literally the very BEST coffee on the Cape and the baked goods leave you with the comfort and warmth of your grandma’s kitchen. The flavors are sophisticated and modern (e.g maple bacon scone -yum! Yes please!) with an ol’ salt Cape Cod charm. Every detail in the shop, from the flavors in the small batch condiment line, to the decor and even the names of the sandwiches and salads, is thoughtfully designed to evoke a love and appreciation for all that makes Cape Cod iconic. Come in and grab a quick coffee and I bet you will find yourself lost in the unique products and the incredible collection of Cape art. Lighthouse keepers has brought the pulse back to the neighborhood — like something we haven’t seen since the good old days when Jack himself was behind his griddle just down the road. It’s exactly what 6-A needs! Thank you Lighthouse Keepers! A++

Christina Filep

Delicious sandwiches, we tried an egg and turkey sandwich, sorry forgot to take a pic. Also enjoyed a scone. The dining area was comfortable and we enjoyed the decor. Brought home some delicious hot pepper jelly too! Looking forward to visiting again

noah czech

three words. cape dory sandwich. the best breakfast sandwich i’ve ever eaten. the staff are friendly and polite and the owner is amazing. the location and the vibe of the shop is totally unmatched. a must try if you’re in the area.

Jennifer S

Amazing to visit this sweet cafe and see how its transformed from selling at farmers markets to an entire shop! Their jelly's are divine! I have been enjoying their ice coffee daily and the cheerful staff 😊

Kendall Ceban

Amazing. The food is high quality, delicious and unique. The atmosphere is friendly and cozy. Hands down the best cinnamon roll I've ever had. Go here!!

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload