Caffè Gelato Bertini

Their homemade gelato was SO good. They offered so many great flavors and were more than happy to let us taste a few. The owners were very friendly and very knowledgeable about their product. I highly recommend stopping by here for gelato and coffee!

Best Gelato on the cape. I love combining flavors too :) They always have new flavors to try.

💯% recommend!

Best gelato around Boston area. They have so many flavors.

The best Gelato ever! It’s so creamy , the flavors are awesome, the owners make the Gelato daily onsite with all fresh ingredients, this is a place to go for Gelato when on the cape

Staff was very nice. Gelato was very good. If you like Gelato try it here

Best gelato I’ve ever had (they used to be in Hyannis). Check their FaceBook page for special flavours. Have to say my favourite is Rum and Raisin. Shop next door has coffee and homemade Key Lime Pie so well worth the trip here.

Usually, I find google reviews reliable but sadly, not here. 7 of us tried several different flavors but unanimously disliked this gelato (ie ice cream with more milk made differently, etc.) when we went the other night and we were all very disappointed given the glowing reviews. It was so average that most of us did not finish it. I want to give it 2-stars but we just didn’t think it was good. It can’t be good when almost everyone prefers to throw away our ice cream rather than finish it, right? I say conclusively and without hesitation, just go somewhere else. 😞

Maybe ownership or recipes changed and we couldn’t totally out our finger on it but heavily suspect they don’t use the highest quality milk and sweeteners and are using various flavorings much more than the actual items from nature (i.e. cherry flavor [natural or artificial is still not a real cherry]).

Given the comments above, it wouldn’t have made a massive difference but while service was efficient and hard-working, it was not particularly friendly.

Before dismissing me as negative fir writing a low rating, please see my other reviews. I try to write detailed, even-handed reviews to help others and have written many glowing reviews about many, many other spots. This place just wasn’t deserving in my (or 6 other visitors) minds based on our experience; far far far from and below its 4.9 review. 🤷‍♂️

Excellent gelato! Just like what we had in Italy! Owners are very nice and the pricing is awesome! We will definitely be back!

This was a magical experience. The owners are so friendly and kind. The gelato was the best I've ever tasted (and I've been to Italy twice-once very recently). The espresso was also lovely.

This place is of what fairytales are made.

I have nothing but good things to say about this place. Its atmosphere is cute as it is just a small house looking building off a side street, with a very hidden vibe. The couple that makes the gelato is very friendly and seems to genuinely enjoy talking about their work and sharing little interesting tidbits with their visitors. I'm unfortunately not a great conversationalist, but they were nice enough to keep one going! And my favorite thing is their falvorings. Their choices ranged from classics anyone can enjoy to far out and exotic flavors (chili chocolate, cardamon, ginger, blood orange, and more I can't recall but wish I had sampled) They rotate out many flavors that aren't the basics, so while you may miss a few, there will always be new stuff. Great place, do yourself a favor and check it out. (I drove 30+ miles for it, and will be going back.)