Search

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • In-store pickup
  • In-store shopping
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Sarah's Cheesecake & Cafe Reviews - 56

4.6
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Destiny Easler

My favorite coffee/pastry spot in Berkshire County! They have great breakfast sandwiches too!

Jennifer Hinckley

We will not be back to Sarah's. My husband and I were on a road trip from Buffalo, NY. We stopped at a bakery very near by which we spent nearly $100. and decided to pop in for a cheesecake. We felt very uncomfortable and the people behind the counter seemed unapproachable. We just chalked it up to not being a regular. Please stop by the bakery, they were amazing. I am sorry I didn't read reviews first.

Penny Gioiello

Very good sandwiches and baked goodies, including cheesecake! Nice people and good service. I recommend the BLT sandwich.

Draegon 1993

I started coming to this lovely place after moving here and it has become my go-to place for breakfast and lunch whenever I feel like getting out of the house. Their breakfast sandwiches are legitimately the best I've ever had around here and their lunch sandwiches are to die for, especially the "Hot Tom." I love their baked goods too, with their muffins and eclairs being my personal favorites. They had apple muffins once too and they were well worth the try.

I decided to try their hummus and pretzels recently, and Katrina was super nice and helpful, she told me about the flavors they have and made a suggestion on the flavor to try. She was even kind enough to quickly whip up some more hummus of the suggested flavor when it turned out there was none left with the rest.

The staff are always friendly and I love getting to chat with them whenever I go in, they make me feel welcome and it's super nice being recognized when I stop in, it shows that they actually care about their customers.

Edit: Their apple crumble pie is absolutely amazing, too!

Pamela Noble

Can't wait to try the champagne cake for Christmas Eve dinner! We stopped in for breakfast Sammies and to order the cake breakfast Sammies we're so hot and freshly made

Shravan Sivakumar

I tried their house blend coffee which was just great! The cheesecakes were delicious as well.

James Noble

They have great sandwiches and always have your order ready quickly.

Ja Kr

Some of the best coffee we've ever had, better than the house blend at the late 59'ers Cafe in West Hartford, which was our previous gold standard. Friendly staff, inexpensive. Muffins and baked goods are excellent as well. Not really the type of place to sit and hang out at, more of a grab and go.

Julia Lewis

Best sandwiches in town! The breakfast sandwiches are amazing and the thanksgiving sandwich is wonderful!! Can’t recommend enough. The people are always so friendly and kind too.

Jacob Doyle

Saw the sign in the little plaza. Stepped in and was greeted with a smile. I asked for recommendations and the freshly made lemon raspberry cupcakes were recommended. Katrina was very thoughtful and friendly and the cupcake was perfect. Everything seem to be made in the house! Even the preserve filling. I am interested in trying many more items they have.

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload