The Creatures' Cauldron Cafe

The drinks were fantastic, the staff were really friendly, the vibes were great, but as a trans person, I felt uncomfortable with how strong the J.K. Rowling theming is. I'd love to make this my regular shop, but I wasn't sure if I'm welcome there or not.

Very friendly and helpful staff and wonderful atmosphere. Excellent homage to Harry Potter!

What an incredible hidden gem!! So glad we came by! Love the decor, the service, the atmosphere, and everything! Make sure to visit next door too!

Love this little coffee shop and sweet spot. Perfect for all your muggle or wizarding needs.

Creatures Cauldron is an absolute Lexington gem 💎 I’m obsessed with every item on the menu and the staff is so amazing and sweet! The owner is so welcoming and the atmosphere is warm and inviting! I know I’ll be a frequent patron here and at her other shop Creatures Of Whim!

Super cute place with incredible coffee! Warm and inviting atmosphere :)

Great little spot, delicious coffee, my cappuccino was absolutely perfect, too bad they don’t serve food, avocado toast or oatmeal won’t hurt. Great overall, specially if you are a Harry Potter fan

This was the cutest place ever! The staff were super nice and I loved the atmosphere. I am not a coffee drinker but they had a chocolate drink that was fantastic.

Amazing service and they were able to customize a drink for me as a tea drinker! Such a great atmosphere as well. Can't wait to go back!

Such a unique and fun experience! No other place else like it in Lexington. My favorite drinks, so far, are the Wolfsbane Potion and the Draught of Deathlike Slumber. Want to try them all!