Casey Coffee Company

In my wife's words, "If I were to start a coffee shop, I would make it exactly like this one. What a charming place!" Family-owned, small town feel, beautiful, thoughtful decor, and most importantly, very delicious coffee, this little shop would not have been out of place on the set of the TV show Smallville.

I loved meeting the owner and hearing her story. We will definitely be back anytime we pass through on I-70.

Give them a try. You won't regret taking a break from Starbucks!

- Rich and Esther

Casey Coffee Company is a hometown coffee shop that is a must visit when you make your pit stop to see the BIG THINGS. Wow what a feeling of friends and family even if your not from Casey. If your not a hot coffee drinker then they also have a wonderful choice of cold drinks as well. And to go along with your drink you can grab a little snack or sweet treat. So when getting off interstate 70 by pass the gas stations to grab that ol cup of joe and head down town to find Casey Coffee Company to get that amazing cup of coffee YOU WILL NOT REGRET IT.

Welcoming atmosphere-amazing products!

I usually LOVE this place. Had a bad experience today though. NO ONE WAS WEARING A MASK. Even though we are in a global pandemic!?!??? The staff had bad communication, and gave 2/TWO different people that came in after us our order. Only after we had to remind them did they get the order togethor.
If the staff had had it togethor, would have had amazing experience. The coffee is GREAT, the food is also really yummy. Slightly over priced but worth it if your surporting small businesses!

Absolutely amazing experience. Staff was polite, helpful and very pleasant to be around. They make it easy to try new things with their variety of different drinks and other menu items. Will definitely go back again!

Casey Coffee Co has my favorite cup of coffee! The staff is always super friendly and the best coffee I’ve had! I love how they are adding to the menu too! Thanks for coming out with the punch cards - I hate to admit how often I fill one up! 😉

Super nice workers! My drink came out really fast (although I was the only one in there).. The coffee tasted really good. The entire cafe was super clean and neat!

Coffee quality that you would find in a big city. Right on Main Street. Great stop if you are traveling 70 and want good coffee that is not the big chain.

Was in the area and came here to get a hot coffee, i tried that campfire one and man let me tell you, it was super delicious, if it was a little bit hotter it would of been the best coffee in the world. You must try the campfire coffee. It’ss nice little cozy spot to, also very close to the attractions.

Imagine the cutest coffee shops and adorable small towns in every Halmark Christmas movie you have ever seen. This is it! A must stop. Stay and enjoy life for a moment.