Foxtail Coffee Co & Kelly’s Ice Cream - San Marco

The caprese panini was pretty disappointing. Bread and sauce was good but it needed like a piece if chicken or something. Hazel donut was amazing, eat with caution the filling is molten lava if you want it heated up. The decor is beautiful and the location is perfect, definitely will be back

First visit after the anticipation of coming to San Marco! My friends and I loved it! The service was awesome, and coffee was very good. We will be back for more!

Coffee was delicious, and I can not say enough about the staff! They were all so friendly. Especially Sarah and Rachel making the coffees. It’s hard to find a place with such personable staff when they are swamped. Keep up the great work!

Inconsistent espresso / coffee quality.

I had high hopes for this new establishment in San Marco. The first time here I ordered a small cappuccino and it was quite fantastic, although the service lacked. I asked them to clear a table on the patio for my use, I set up on it and pushed the used tray and cup to the side but they didnt come until almost 45min later.

The second time, which was today, the cappuccino and a latte came out overly hot and burnt making them complete trash. Very disappointing considering this a coffee Cafe first, then small plates and ice cream second. You would expect a certain quality and consistency from a place like this, hopefully they are still just ironing out the kinks and will not disappoint again as I'd like to love this place and make it a regular go-to cafe.

As an original Orlando customer, I’m beyond disappointed in my coffee here. Just paid $7 basically for a cup of milk (and milk dripping down the side of the cup). The latte was super light and you couldn’t even taste the coffee.

My experience with coffee for most of my life has been like with wine: there are probably about five people who really can manage complexity, and the rest of us just like what we like. I want to think I’m the former, but I’m likely the latter.

That said, the coffee at Foxtail checks all the right boxes. But more than that (because listen, Sally, you still have your Keurig at home, right), I value the total package on an incredibly important corner of San Marco. Ambiance, comfort, style, and attention to detail. If experience matters, then I can’t recommend Foxtail more highly.

There’s a lot of great ice cream places in San Marco but this might have the best ice cream around. I had the chocolate cookie dough and I hope it stays on the menu.

These people with the 1 Star reviews are your typical “1 star types” …nothing is ever good enough.
I’ve been 3x this week and it’s been great. Love the staff, coffee is great and a fantastic location. ***try the Choc croissant, delish.
As a matter of fact, the proprietor was hands on washing windows and teaching his staff on opening morning how to use the computer system!!!
He’s in it to win it and local.

Foxtails never disappoint. This one was slammed on opening weekend and the young staff were doing their best to get everyone in and out. I love their coconut cold brew, and the atmosphere was great too. Will be back to this one.

They keep all the ceramic cups hidden to make it look better, per the order taker lady. They have the plastic and paper cups on display. Cortado was ordered specifically in a ceremic or glass but was first made and put in paper Togo cup. "Barista" was not excited to make it again as she wanted to dump it into a ceremic from the paper a d be done with it. She did make it again in the ceremic. The espresso shot volume was above traditional double shot as I could see. Cortado was listed as 4 oz but my ceremic was not 4. I'm not excited about a place that showcases plastic and paper cups and hides the reusable, unless owners are pro oil and disposable items, then cool.