New Moon Cafe

I could not love this place more if I tried! So cute, so quaint, so local... And they have a make your own bloody Mary bar!! What is not to love!

The younger woman behind the counter is super helpful and friendly and the food she made for us was more than adequate! Giving only four stars because the middle-aged woman there was not helpful and really not too friendly, in my opinion, and seems to have gotten a bit too comfy with the self service for customers platform.

They have always been nice to me. Food was always yummy. Have had to wait longer than I expected before but hey it's a resort. Overall great place.

I so badly want to see restaurants in the Keystone village succeed but I just can’t recommend New Moon. I had a buffalo wing quesadilla and it was very disappointing. Tortilla very sparingly filled with grilled chicken and a bit of blue cheese. No melty cheese reminiscent of a good quesadilla. Very small portion for the price, with tip I paid $17, totally ridiculous price for what I got. Sorry New Moon but you have to do much better.

Lol, I go thru all the trouble of walking in ski boots to get a cup of coffee from here (3 bucks) try to pay w a 20, they have no changes. How can they operate a business and can't break a $20? So I went to the inkspot for coffee

Dont come here unless you have hours to kill. We arrived right as they opened and not a single person in the restaurant was served until 30 minutes later. In fact, I'm still sitting here waiting nearly an hour after ordering (I was #4 in line since opening) and may never eat again.

UPDATE: The food finally arrived. It was not good.

Ok.. I am in Florida.. my son was getting married in Keystone and I had to host
the rehearsal dinner. It was a challenge doing it long distance and I was worried until I found NEW MOON CAFE!! The owner Barb and I worked via email and it
turned out to be a HUGE success! We hosted over 60 people and had a fantastic selection of Panini's, Salad, Homemade chips and salsa, hot pretzels with cheese,
home made desserts and a wonderful selection of wine and beer along with mixed drinks. We had the entire place to ourselves ( inside and great patio) and a terrific guitarist (Todd) who played throughout the night. Now I have hosted parties.. my
daughter got married at the Ritz but I have to tell you everyone had a fabulous time
and are still raving about Barb's fantastic staff and the fun they had!
I hope that anyone who is considering hosting an event or just stopping by
check out this wonderful place. It will forever be a part of our fondest memories!

In case anyone was wondering, this is how much orange juice you get for $6.

Best happy hour in the keystone Village: Wide selection of cheap craft cans. Highest quality to price ratio in the village for food. The owner is amazing and friendly.

Okay food, but it was overpriced. Raw potatoes in our burrito and hair in another burrito sure didn't leave us with a great feeling. But if want a bottled drink, this would be a good place for you though.