Bagelmania Coffee House

Yummy! Everything there is good! It smells amazing inside, & it's always fresh.

I have been coming here for years. Over the past few years I noticed the change in service& their bagels. The bagels taste old, extra chewy or burnt. Like other reviews it's a long wait. Lastly it leaves a bad taste in my mouth watching management reprimand an employee in front of you...nobody wants to see that. I feel bad for the young man running the drive thru window. Time to find a new bagel place.

Overall rating- this place is OK.

The bagels are average. Not amazing, but certainly eatable. If I were to base this place on food only, would prob give it 3.5 stars.

The reason I am giving it 2 stars is because of the wait in the drive thru. It should not take 30+ minutes for bagels. This is a popular place and it’s good they get a lot of business, but it’s not worth waiting this long for bagels. I may try again if the line is shorter.

If you are looking for a place in HB with quality bagels and excellent service, try Bo’s Bagels and Coffee on Hamilton.

If you are reading complaints about horrible service and horrible bagels, you might want to ask yourself why are they so busy. I personally have had great service. Yes, it sometimes take a little while to get your bagel if you show up during "hangover hour" on Saturday or Sunday morning. Great outdoor seating that blocks the wind and is heated if needed. Nice people and they accept wireless payments for people like me who forget wallets but never my phone.

My boyfriend took me here for the first time and believe me when I tell you that the drive thru line was absolutely insane. But it was totally worth it for the bagels! I got a blueberry bagel with plain cream cheese and my boyfriend got a cheese bagel with cream cheese. I was definitely happy with my bagel but I think I will be trying an onion or everything bagel on my next visit after a little bit of onion made its way into my order (and it was my favorite bite). My boyfriend was not overly enthusiastic about his cheese bagel saying his usual order of the sesame bagel is better, but he was still happily chowing down his bagel. My one negative mark is that their regular coffee was horrible, I didn't even want to finish drinking it because it almost tasted like they used spoiled creamer. Definitely worth the wait for bagels but I would stick to their fancy coffee menu if you're looking for a cup. I will be back for more

We frequently visit this location and it’s usually great! But the past 3 mornings we went here simply for bagels and waited 40+ Min in the drive through every single day. Today we pulled up with only a few cars in the line and still waited 40+ min, had a rude cashier and top it all off we got the shitties bagels I’ve ever had from here. It does not take 40 Min to toast bagels, or build sandwiches. I’ve worked in the food industry for many years, this is not efficient. Needless to say we will not be returning. Get it together Bagelmania, highly disappointed.

Terrific coffee (Hazelnut is amazing). Refreshing & healthy smoothies. Delicious bagels, all flavors. Great sandwiches. Their jalapeno cheese bagel toasted with cream cheese tastes like nachos!!! SO YUMMY!! Get a frequent customer card & have it stamped each time to earn your freebie coffee or smoothie. Usually a wait but worth it!

Wonderful bagels!! Great staff!
But I this time just tried the fresh orange juice. Not good and NOT fresh. I called back and it wasn't fresh orange juice it comes out of a bottle. And not a good brand even. I just paid $4 for bottled juice Labeled as fresh on menu 😣

This was my first time coming, and it was HORRIBLE.. I waited in a 20min line then when I got my order they forgot the creamcheese no big deal so I went it and talked to the lady she was super sweet But when I got my bagels and I went to my car they gave me soggy cold Begals they put so much creamcheese u can tell they were just being rude about it. First and last time coming in

This place is fantastic. Great bagels perfectly crisp and chewy. I come here with my kids 2 and 8 years olds all the time and they love it too. VERY generous with the cream cheese.😆 The tuna salad bagel sandwich is the perfect lunch after yoga at the Y.