Reviews (100)
Absolutely the best meal I’ve ever had at a Wyoming restaurant and I’ve lived here for 15 years. The staff was friendly and helpful. The steak was perfect. The lamb shank was even better. The dessert was a crème brûlée dish that was unique and fresh. The smashed potatoes were to die for. The chef was super friendly and very caring. Dude is the man, and I’m a total foodie saying this.
Beautiful experience and the food was fabulous! I had the lamb shank, herb potatoes and Brussel sprouts! It was superb. Their bruschetta was the best I have ever had. And to top it off a very delicious crème brûlée served with meringue. Highly recommend!
I hadn't been here in years and I knew it was under someone new but we took a chance, and I'm so glad we did! We both had the special of the evening, a ribeye with Brussel sprouts and fingerling potatoes. The steak came with an incredible cream sauce and everything had amazing flavor. The chef came out to visit with us and the waitress was very friendly. The setting is beautiful, as it always has been. I didn't think to take pictures until I was done devouring my meal! I really don't like potatoes and usually eat just a bit of them, but I even loved the potatoes. I finally had to stop eating before I popped!
We went to see how the place has changed under new ownership. The atmosphere is very pleasant, they sometimes have live music, which is cool and they’re adding a library, also cool. You might want to check the menu before going there, though. It’s extremely limited, “utilizing “ ( they utilize the word “utilize” to death in their menu) beef tallow in the brioche. The upscale menu is very limited and overpriced. We had hoped the new owners would bring it back to its original glory. It used to be a popular place to take friends and family from out of state, but I would not recommend that now. It’s apparently run by a DAO now and the locals say they’re not welcome there. We looked at the menu and decided to go elsewhere. You might want to look at the menu online first to see if it interests you.
Amazing!!!! We had the pork belly ends, crispy brussel sprouts and the wagon burger which was the best burger I’ve ever had! Everything was seriously phenomenal. Can’t wait to go back!
The new ownership is amazing. The vision for the Wagon Box is only going to get better. Looking forward to many more burgers and espressos! Biscuits and gravy are tops!
Feels like home. Ribeye and biscuits and gravy were exactly as they should be, best Cabernet I’ve ever had. Warm fire, Cosy family-friendly atmosphere, host of as welcoming and genuine, staff were attentive and professional.
Fantastic! Best experience I’ve had in a very long time. Highly recommend. Owner is super cool too. Will be back soon.
The Wagon Box-we ate at your restaurant for the first time yesterday for breakfast. (New to town as well) I have to say our breakfast was fantastic! The biscuits and gravy were the best I've had. We missed you for Prime Rib dinner last night, but will be back soon. Thank you for a great meal! It has been a challenge in Sheridan to get such.
Starting to become the go to place for breakfast
This restaurant is under new management and they're doing a phenomenal job! Warm, welcoming, atmosphere, great service, delicious food, impressive wine and craft beer selection. What a hidden gem, will definitely be back!
Excellent food, fun family environment and good occasional music, cultural events
Great food and such a friendly staff! Plus the locale is beautiful——————a must see !!!♪(ﾟ▽^*)ﾉ⌒☆
New owners have the right idea. Upscale comfort food with classy touches, good coffee, good beers on tap, and great staff. An oasis
We were working in the area and it was the only place open. We sat at the bar. Like many local establishments, the "Bar Keep" does everything. It was great. She treated us like we come in everyday. I had the chicken strip combo plate. She took our orders, disappeared into the back, since she quadruples as the cook, and came back shortly with our plates. Food was presented very well. Taste was excellent, service wonderful. We went again the next day.... Surprisingly, an acquaintance I hadn't seen in years was there .. if you like a home style at.osphere, it is definitely the place to go.
Literally my worst dinning experience in my life. Spent nearly $200 and only had 3 out of 9 orders decent. Servers were high on something. Not enough space here to explain everything that was wrong at this place. Was told we would get a big discount for our poor experience. 6 percent "discount" is offensive. Was listed on ticket as "veteran discount" . Won't be back. Pitty because I've always had great food and service previously
October 1, 2021. Restaurant is in some kind of transition. The website is inaccurate.
Good food at a fair price, they were out of several menu items
The waitress was wonderful and the food was good. I had the 2 piece broasted chicken. The salad bar was not good.
Excellent ownership, management, and staff, absolutely friendly place to stay at in the mountains area of story Wyoming