Reviews (44)
First time customer ! Super pleasant experience! Can't wait to return.
I cannot recommend Slice of Heaven Bakery enough! They provided the dessert table for our welcome reception at our wedding at Sand Valley, and it was simply incredible. From the first time we messaged with the Rebecca, we knew we were in good hands. She is professional, responsive, and so accommodating to our requests (and last minute changes/additions). She even delivered all the items to our location. On the day of the event, the dessert table was set up beautifully, and the desserts themselves were out-of-this-world delicious. Our guests were raving about the selection, which included everything from cookies to chocolate pretzels to cupcakes. The presentation was stunning, and we were so impressed with the attention to detail. Overall, Slice of Heaven Bakery made our welcome reception absolutely perfect. We are so grateful for their hard work and would recommend them to anyone looking for top-notch baked goods and service. We do our best to visit Slice of Heaven each time we are in Rome! Thank you, Rebecca!
Nancy Hagerty here! Just a quick review of Slice of Heaven Bakery! If I could give more than a 5 star review , I certainly would! But for now, a 5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️, a 5 👏👏👏👏👏,a 5 👍👍👍👍👍 and a most sincere Thank You to Your staff who are simply Wonderful! Your products are Heavenly! We Appreciate all that you do! 😇
Rebecca is an excellent baker and an even better human. Slice of Heaven is lovely.
Unfortunately was unable to try this apparently nice place. Drove with the whole family, to find out they had closed before business hours. “Sold out” sign on the door.
Rome is so blessed to have this business here. Having the owner's dream come true by opening this bakery shows in the quality of her product. Her cakes are works of art and equally delicious. Cupcakes are another of her specialties. Her scones are my favorite bakery item. It's a great idea to order ahead if you can. Her items are always fresh so quantities may be limited. I also love Rebecca's chai lattes! So glad to see new Sunday hours for spring/summer now!
I heard about this bakery and how good their cookies were; so I went on an adventure and drove out from Plover just to give it a try. I was absolutely blown away. We tried 4 different cupcake varieties and 6 cookies. The cupcakes were the most flavorful I have ever had. So fluffy and moist - completely blown away. The raspberry lemonade was probably top 3 of any cupcake I’ve ever had (and I’m a baker)! I would make the drive again just to try a new flavor of cupcake. The cookies were soft but still a bit crunchy and super delicious. Salted caramel, s’mores and kitchen sink were my favorites. 10/10 would recommend
Fabulous service, and amazing baked goods!
Great service, cute coffee shop!
Cinnamon roll was big and could taste it was home made. The sweet cream vanilla cold brew tasted like straight milk and sugar.. didn’t seem to have any coffee taste to it or look like it. Recommend to order black for drinks.
I can't say enough about the folks
Great cappuccino and homemade bread. Great addition to Rome! The staff is super friendly too.
A special treat!
We stop in from time to time for a sweet treat, they never disappoint!!! My wife grabbed some Kaiser rolls yesterday…. Best I have EVER had!!! Nice and light, soft but toast well. Absolutely amazing, we will make it a regular stop in our weekly routine weather we have a sweet tooth or not!!!!
Get there early. The stuff is so dang good that it's gone before you know it.
Everything we’ve had has been excellent at worst, the English muffin bread is absurdly good. Very reasonably priced for the quality. Easily the best bakery we’ve found since moving up to central WI. Lives up to its name!
Very nice people that run this shop. Haven't had an item yet that I didn't love.
No better bakery anywhere on planet earth. Best staff ever. I love this place!!!
Where to begin? My wife Samm and I have known Rebecca since she worked at ODC in Rapids. Because of her wonderful people skills, genuine personality, and immediate warmth, we were delighted when she and her husband upended “Slice of Heaven” in Rome, WI. No longer a need to travel to the other Rome or Vienna for her delicious “treats from the heart!” One more accolade as to how genuine Rebecca is: I happened to be in Riverview Hospital for a few days, of which wife Samm told her while picking up my favorite cinnamon coffee cake. Alas, who walked into my room today with her Slice of Heaven smile and treats?! Remember, she starts baking at 2:30AM. She took precious time because of who she is. Thank you, Rebecca and your wonderful SLICE OF HEAVEN. Pat & Samm
Do you love bread? Do you love sweets? Then you have to visit Slice of Heaven Bakery in the Town of Rome, Wisconsin. We first visited New Years Eve and walked away with 2 humongous Iced Cinnamon Rolls, Parmesan Garlic Bread, Cranberry Walnut Bread, and a scone. Our family guests, as well as ourselves, raved over the quality and flavor of these grand items. The ambiance is very inviting, the owners are exceptionally friendly, and the whole bakery experience is fantastic. Today we stopped after our workout and sat a bit sipping on our perfectly created lattes and the Iced Cinnamon Roll we shared. We enjoyed the cozy atmosphere and the wonderful comfort the owners provide. Of course we also left with the Cranberry Walnut Bread, which makes the best toast! Whether you are passing through town, visiting the area golf courses, or staying a bit in the Lakes area, stop and be awed by the reasonable priced bakery items and coffees you won’t find anywhere else in the area. Bravo, Slice of Heaven Bakery!