Reviews (100)
I've been disappointed many times by this establishment, but last night was the worst. Not only was my order incorrect, but I also had drinks spilled on my by the bartender. They advertise many drinks, but rarely have anything in stock. Id recommend any other restaurant in town.
My boyfriend and I have been on a hunt for a really good Chicken Alfredo. We've been far and wide trying to find one as good as Olive Garden without all the miles it takes to go there. At Casali's, we found a mini olive garden. The Alfredo sauce was wonderful! Definitely worth a try! They've got a million and one beverages to try and home made desserts!
Coming in on a busy Friday night,we expected a wait. We, however, didn't have any service/attention from our waitress for over 30 minutes. I have no problem with waiting, but she didn't even ask about refilling coffee or other drinks.
The service is fantastic and the atmosphere is comfortable!! The food isn't bad! (I'm spoiled from the Erie Italian restaurants)
Great service and food and the prices are extremely reasonable.
Will most definitely return. Our entire food order was outstanding. I was surprised at the ease of using the online ordering system and the availability of options they have set. Great meal.
Very good food at very good prices. I had the Steak and Gorgonzola Fettuccine Alfredo pasta. My gf had the Four Cheese Ravioli in Diablo sauce. Both were delicious.
Our favorite place to eat! The food is the best, although the menu is limited. Great bar, fun fancy drinks and a superb bartender. The servers all all very helpful and attentive. Our favorites: sausage potato soup, steak salads (prime cuts of meat as ordered), and steak Gorgonzola! It’s the first place I’d take out of Townes for a great meal and service.
Grabbed takeout this evening. I do not recommend the Portobello mushroom ravioli under any circumstances. Straight out of the freezer and flavorless. My wife ordered an Italian hoagie and stated “she could get a better one at foxes pizza.” We both threw our meals away after only being able to eat half. I type this review sad, hungry and disappointed.
Wonderful first visit to Casali’s Grille! We were looking for nearby restaurants when coming to the Benezette area, and we found a winner here in St. Mary’s. Our server was spot on with service! We found out she had been on the floor only a week and previous experience was working at a sub shop. It was obvious she received some quality training at Casali’s. The food was very nice. Presentation, Flavor and quality was evident in every course. We definitely are coming back! Update 2022: We have been back and our last visit was as good as before. Looking forward to our next!
We walked in the door and asked if they showed the Penn State games on Saturday on their TV and the girl that seated us told us the TV was broken. When we were seated we noticed that at least 2 of the TVs were working????? It was only Friday and we were planning to stop back on Saturday but felt like we were not welcome. But the food was absolutely the best burgers ever!
I had the chicken florentine wrap it was very tastey.
Service was good, food was great, overall experience was great. Definitely will go back there for lunch or dinner.
Great food great prices awesome service
Had lunch today our food was disgusting. Your tartar sauce was vile. There were dead bugs on window ledge and our table. Your saving grace was the chocolate cake you didn’t make. Your restrooms are filthy. Your place was recommended.
I love the place. It's my favorite in St.Mary's. One Monday night there was a party and another group gathering so we had to wait an hour for the food we(2 guests) ordered. They were short on staff so I understand. Otherwise, the service is amazing, food taste delicious and the menu choices is just right.
Food is stupendous, service also! Call ahead as it gets pretty busy. Great atmosphere too!
Very good chicken salad. I will request more chicken next time though not enough protein as a meal for me. My friend had the goganzola steak and pasta with their potato soup which was excellent. Highly recommended.
Fantastic service and food. Very much looking forward to our next visit!!
Wonderful food and friendly staff. We got our food quickly. I would definitely recommend it!