Reviews (100)
We just moved to the area trying new places and my husband ordered the chicken Marsala it was so bland and didn’t look like it. I ordered the chicken piccata no sauce either?
We ordered some drinks and found out on the bill that each small glass filled with mostly ice was at least $14 each, definitely overpriced. Our server forgot our appetizer and we didn't get a croissant with the entrée, not a big deal but a lil disappointed since I was looking forward to it. The food took a while to come out. Some positives: lots of options on the menu with descriptions, comfy atmosphere, plenty seating. Overall, compared to similar restaurants, it's expensive and not worth the small portions, but it's the only one of its kind in the area.
Wide selection of food and drinks and the best coffee. ALWAYS excellent service , staff is friendly and helfpul. The owner is so kind. Would always reccomend! Try the old world, trust me. 😊
Have eaten here multiple times. The lasagna is very good. Most of the food is very good . My only complaint is for an Italian restaurant they are really cheap with the bread. They give you 4 pieces of bread for 4 people. I asked for more bread and told the waitress I would pay for the extra bread. She gave us an additional 4 pieces and charged us $2.00 for it. Can't eat Italian food without bread!!! Below I'm sharing picture with Carini of an Italian restaurant Capri in Orange County NY. Now, this is how bread is served in an Italian restaurant! This was the second basket of toasted garlic bread they brought out and they didn't charge me!
Had Sicilian pie with peperoni and onion Quite good
My husband & I Ordered our meals. I ordered a lemon tea, appetizer, and entre. I received a raspberry tea. had to send it back. When our meals came out we asked why we never received our appetizer. She said it's coming out now. We told her we no longer wanted it, as it was supposed to be an appetizer. As we were eating we noticed that all the other tables had salad and bread. We were never asked about a salad nor were we served either! I looked at a menu on my way out & it says all entrees come with a side of salad & baguettes .I will never go to this place again.
The absolute most disgusting place I’ve ever been I order 50$ intake out the calamari was 15$ and was frozen shoe leather I was so disappointed as this was our first time trying carinis and it took us a long time to try it because the prices were very expensive. We live in the Milford area and there’s a lot of amazing places to eat so I feel like this place will not last much longer because it’s absolutely disgusting and I will post pictures
Local Restaurant with brick oven pizza and other choices. Beer choices Mixed drinks Coffee Expresso Gelato Hot heros Specialty plates
This is one of the best restaurants around. Think they need to do better in timely manner of serving food and food should be served hot on hot plates.
Absolutely lights out quality, fresh and delicious! Nice atmosphere to sit and enjoy the way things ought to be when you dine out! Accommodated a party of 7 walk-in and crushed it for us! We got 4 appetizers, 4 large pies, requested to try their cutlet a la carte and ordered all 5 gelato flavors and they nailed everything! We grabbed a Freddo matcha and a flat white to go and watched them whip both up and once again…knock out punch on both! The matcha was extremely fresh and flavorful! The service was outstanding! We WILL be back! A diamond in the rough out here in the hills of Pa!
The pizza was absolutely amazing. My friends and I loved everything we tried. Make sure to try their house made gelato. 🤤
Really disappointed with the quality of food and the pricing. I would expect something more from a location way out in the sticks because, well, they have the market cornered LOL We got a Chicken Parm dinner, large pizza with pepperoni, salad and 2 cannoli. I don't remember the exact price but MAN ALIVE it was expensive. The chicken parm dinner was undercooked and drowning in sauce, the pizza was hard as a rock with very little cheese or pepperoni and the cannoli were TINY and DRY. The salad was alright but hard to mess that up, especially if its premade. I dont usually post or read reviews but I felt like this needed to be said for people who have never eaten here and are thinking about going. Its a disappointment to be fair.
Reliably decent food. Step up from mediocre. Good ambience and appropriate pricing.
Had better food from John's of Arthur Ave. I'm long past the stage in my life where I'm eating ambiance.
First of all, ALL PRAISES TO THE MOST HIGH! As usual, CARINI always comes thru! Coming from the Bronx, pizza was always all around me. So altho not being my usual go-to shop, i was impressed by their selection and FRESHNESS. The pizza man KNOWS WHAT HE'S DOING. Not to s*** on the other shop(brother brunos), but Carinis IS HANDS DOWN the best shop around Hemlock... i used to rock with Brunos, but Carinis blew them out the water. Yeah, you pay for what you get; but living in Hemlock, if you could afford an AUDI, you could afford Carinis...
Descent food for the most part, but not worth the horrific attitude of those who work there. Poor customer service and no attention to detail. I gave it a few chances, but refuse to go back or order take-out again.
Modern, casual dining with a nice bar. Food was perfectly prepared and seasoned. Portions were just right- not too big and not too small. Service was friendly and attentive. I really enjoyed my meal (Chicken Messina) and plan to dine there again soon with friends.
Very high quality food….best Italian in 18337
The pizza was delicious and I had the pecan apple salad which was good even the next day. I would go back to sit for lunch
We were a group of 19 people and we all enjoyed the food so much 😋 everything we ordered was tasty. Service was superb 👌