Real Coffee Club
Ice cream shopIce cream shop

Bagelarium & STG Gelateria Broken Arrow

★★★★½ 4.7/5 (100 reviews)
$$
217 S Main St, Broken Arrow, OK 74012 (918) 957-1910 Website
Bagelarium & STG Gelateria Broken Arrow Bagelarium & STG Gelateria Broken Arrow Bagelarium & STG Gelateria Broken Arrow Bagelarium & STG Gelateria Broken Arrow Bagelarium & STG Gelateria Broken Arrow

Reviews (100)

Joey Efird
Joey Efird
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

The customer service was great. The gelato was wonderful.

David Stiles
David Stiles
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Great place to find a cold delicacy on a hot day and a yummy treat on other days! So many flavor choices.

Gage Coldwater
Gage Coldwater
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

I really enjoyed the Gelato here. They have lots of vegan options as well which I really appreciated. I liked the strawberry best and the limoncello was delicious as well. It is in a great area and the staff was supper friendly and the store is clean and inviting. I highly recommend this great place! I can't wait to go back and try the bagels at some point as well!

Michael Weber
Michael Weber
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Had a bagel with bacon cream cheese and tomato. Great Gelato as well

Danielle Meadows
Danielle Meadows
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Always delicious and pleasant. They also have a few boardgames which I appreciate.

Jessica Davis
Jessica Davis
★★★★☆ Jan 20, 1970

Wonderful place! Make sure to ask for sample flavors beforehand and enjoy 😊🍨 Vegan options are amazing as well!!!

Basil Malik
Basil Malik
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Super friendly people behind the counter, and they don't get annoyed if you ask to get a tiny spoonful of every flavor. The flavors are all delicious from the ones that I've tried, but my go-to is definitely the pistachio. Bonus points for laughing at the plethora of dad jokes. :)

Clint Griffith
Clint Griffith
★★★★☆ Jan 20, 1970

Plain seaseme bagel or the canolli

C Davis
C Davis
★★★★☆ Jan 20, 1970

Carry vegan Ice cream.

JC PENNY
JC PENNY
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

OMG! the turkey avocado bagel was soooooo good and so much of a "sandwich" I almost couldn't finish it. much better than Panera's Turkey BLT...soooo much better.

Tim Airhart
Tim Airhart
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Made a special trip while in Tulsa visiting friends. Our favorite gelato place in Oklahoma! Good selection delicious smooth gelato and good value.

Emma Leffler
Emma Leffler
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

I have now visited both the Tulsa Cherry Street location and this location- this is one of the best gelato/ice cream places in Oklahoma! Very clean inside, staff knowledgeable about the ingredients in the Gelato, and games inside to play with while eating. We got the Biscoff and Stracciatella gelato (medium size) and the Unicorn and Pistachio (medium size). If you love Trader Joe's Cookie Butter or the Biscoff cookies you will love the Biscoff gelato! The Stracciatella flavor tastes like chocolate chip ice cream! My boyfriend really enjoyed the pistachio flavor but not the Unicorn flavor. He mentioned he wasn't sure what the true flavor tasted like but that he wouldn't get that again. Our advice is to ask for samples to try to make sure you enjoy the gelato! The serving sizes are huge and great to share as well!

Erin Haines
Erin Haines
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

I got the super dark chocolate & my daughter got the Unicorn. Both were great!

Jon Westberg
Jon Westberg
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

The ladies working when we arrived were friendly and our bagels and gellato were delicious.

Ashton Chatman
Ashton Chatman
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Made an order through doordash the bagels are really good! Salmon Lox bagel is great super fresh love all the spreads my fave is the churro one. Will be back 😊

Drew Erickson
Drew Erickson
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Such a friendly staff and really good gelato! We loved walking in this area and shopping great area

Julie Collier
Julie Collier
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Delicious gelato & cute atmosphere

Sean Shenold
Sean Shenold
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Fabulous gelato, smooth, creamy, very rich and flavorful. Great service, with great coffee, too. They've got a number of table and board games for patrons to spend some time, have some fun, and enjoy their wonderful offerings. Great place to stop in for a while.

John Huskins
John Huskins
★★★★☆ Jan 20, 1970

It was good, very overpriced but good. The staff was very friendly.

Aaron Hardison
Aaron Hardison
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Cannoli’s are outstanding!