Reviews (100)
Pleasant shop and the young lady that helped me was friendly and patient. Unfortunately, a couple of the cupcakes didn’t seem fresh, specifically the butter beer cupcake which was very hard and honestly just inedible. Maybe I caught them on an off day.
Got my daughters 13th birthday cake custom made. They did a fabulous job and got the design right, and the cake was moist and everyone loved it.
I decided to try the brownie that has cheesecake in the middle. The brownie was no better quality than the brownies served at Roy Rogers fast food, meaning the taste was not great. Plus the brownies are small. I was not impressed.
Great customer service, we went on a Sunday afternoon, I got the key lime cheesecake, it was refreshing and delicious, I tore it up before taking a photo, 😩sorry but my son got the cupcakes, and vanilla pudding and I got the photo of those🤗
i’ve ordered off of uber eats so I know the treats are good! but my first time coming in the girl in the front seemed a little rushed or on edge despite there not really being a crowd. I asked for a vanilla cone with sprinkles and got a bowl with barely any sprinkles. my cone fell off because it wasn’t ice cream in it to begin with :/
I’ve been to Sweet Tooth many times. Everything I’ve tried has been delicious!! The cheesecake slices, pecan pie squares, cookies and cupcakes were all great. My dogs love the doggie treat bars! Very nice, helpful staff.
We ordered a Birthday Cake for our Mother’s 95th birthday from Sweet Tooth Bakery. The Sweet Tooth staff were very nice and made suggestions to help us with our order. The cake turned out so beautiful and it was absolutely delicious. I can’t tell you how excited my Mother was when she saw her birthday cake. She loved it! Thank you Sweet Tooth Bakery for making her 95th birthday so special.
This bakery is phenomenal. When we moved to the area, my daughter’s birthday was coming up, and with an allergy, I needed a Vegan shop for a cake. We ordered a jumbo cupcake, and not only was it incredibly affordable, but it was also possibly the best cupcake I’ve had ever. Since then we’ve stopped in for small treats an I’ve never had anything that was not amazing. Absolutely recommend!
Everything bet is DELICIOUS! The customer service is excellent, as well. The gluten free cupcakes are the best I’ve ever tasted!!!!
I have had many items from The Sweet Tooth. The macaroons are yummy. I love the cupcakes always spot on. My granddaughter loves the keto cheesecake. I have ordered 3 specialty cakes made for my grands birthdays always what I asked for. I also love to have a cup of the ice cream. The customer service has always been amazing. They go above and beyond in my book.
They have the best cupcakes flavors!!
Cupcakes were ok. More like muffins with frosting.
Thank you sweet tooth shop for making an exceptionally delicious cake and cup cakes for my wedding reception.
Hershey ice cream friendly services. I'm coming back to try the coffee and other goodies. Cheese cake, cup cakes, cookies, regular cakes, and vegan options it all looked great.
Huge variety of different kinds of sweets and flavors. Very clean and relaxed atmosphere. The cupcakes and coffee were delicious!!
Only two flavors for gluten free, but they taste incredible. Very moist, rich flavor, and the icing compliments it perfectly.
I’ve visited this shop multiple times. Every time I get the best costumer service. Every item in there is amazing. The cheesecake and cupcakes are my absolute favorite. Also, I love that they have something for everyone.
I’m sorry … this my first time trying this spot today and everyone taste buds are different but my cupcakes were so dry , I thought I was in the Sahara desert . The icing was okay though . Edit : I got a Oreo cheesecake as well &’ it was deliciousssssssssss . I would definitely purchase that again . Lol
Okay so.... I purchased two cupcakes, a piece of cheesecake, and two macarons. Macaroons had that perfect crunchy/chewiness that not everybody can capture. Delicious! The cheesecake was really good. I like a little bit more tart but still VERY creamy and delicious. The cupcakes is where it gets dicey. The cake was moist and had a great taste. Great bite. Not too crumbly but still soft and fluffy. The icing however was a let down. I got a strawberry and a birthday cake. The birthday cake wasn't too bad but the icing on the strawberry cupcake tasted like straight oil. I felt like I was eating a strawberry flavored whipped olive oil. It was gross. I was confused bc the strawberry flavored came through but the oil was just too overpowering. Maybe just a fluke. But not a fan.
The Sweet Tooth Shop has a fantastic selection of specialty cupcakes. I haven’t found one that I have not fallen in love with. While I am not the biggest Red Velvet Cake fan, the Sweet Tooth’s Red Velvet Cupcakes haunt my dreams! The frosting is incredible and the cupcake is so moist. I also love the traditional birthday and wedding flavored cupcakes. I am going to try the strawberry and lemon on my next visit. The cheesecake is pretty good. However, I love the cupcakes more. I have only seen the cakes, so while I can’t vouch on the flavor, the ones that I have seen have been exceptionally beautiful.