Reviews (81)
I just loved the Cassandra club and the goat cheese Mac and cheese and it's all great prices
Sunday is the day my sister and I take my 88 yr old Dad out for breakfast. Haven’t been happy with our experience at a Cobleskill Diner in the past, so we decided to take a scenic drive. We googled restaurants and The Black Cat came up. We found a diamond in the rough. What a quaint little cafe that reminded us of the 50’s. Food was yummy and the owner was very accommodating. Will definitely be back.
Was just okay. Small portion and not enough vegan options.
Super cute cafe, really enjoyed my lunch date here.
Good prices for great items. Everything from there was very good including the chocolate croissant, blueberry muffin and the donuts. The workers are very sweet and kind.
It was a Fantastic lunch as Always! Tony and his crew are great! Thank you for all you do! ❤️
Love this place, and the owner is fantastic. Had the most amazing meals. It's worth the ride to take a scenic ride to this historic village and get a bite to eat.
Charming cafe. The food is great, home made, definitely made with love. My only complaint is that for the price (which is on the high side) I expect something to come with my sandwich, maybe a small side of salad or a few fries or even a pickle? A sandwich always tastes better when it has a companion to nibble on. And it would look so much more appealing on the plate. I will take a picture next time I eat there to show what I mean.
I love this place! Good food!
I never would have stopped here if a friend hadn't taken me. If fact, I wouldn't have even turned down the street off the main highway. The four of us had various sandwiches which were outstanding. If you want a breakfast or lunch spot worth trying, instead of the ordinary chain place, cardboard food substance, this is your place.
Great place, good sandwiches, everything fresh, coffee good, try the espresso!
A lovely little cafe that serves amazing food! It is a must to stop and eat here when you are in town!
If you find yourself at the Canajoharie Exit on the New York Thruway around lunch time, exit and drive south for 15 minutes to Sharon Springs where you will find the Black Cat Cafe and Bakery. Treat yourself to the daily homemade soup or fresh green salad with figgy balsamic vinegar and one of the eclectic sandwiches that have been perfected by the owner/host, Tony, over many years. The picture shows 1/2 of the Thanksgiving Everyday sandwich to the left and 1/2 of the Reuben sandwich to the right. The turkey is roasted on site and comes with delicious homemade cranberry sauce and stuffing, and the corned beef is the leanest and most delicious I've had in a long time. It is also possible to order boxed lunches delivered to the Glimmerglass Theater in Cooperstown. We've always enjoyed these meals when attending performances there. After lunch enjoy browsing nearby shops, including the Beekman 1802 Mercantile.
Atmosphere and service were good, but the food was disappointing. Corned beef sandwich was no comparison to a favorite from a Schenectady deli. Cider donuts were hard, bitter, and bone-dry. Plus actual dirt in a salad's poorly rinsed lettuce. Shame because the place was charming.
Wonderful little cafe with delicious, wholesome food. The chicken salad on raisin bread was fabulous! Soup was excellent also!
Always hits the spot
The sandwiches have alwsys been delicious, but 3 times in a row we bought baked good, such as croissants to go and they were stale.
The steak sandwich is the world's best, if available. The breakfast potatoes were great as well. Actually, all the food at our table was exceptional and unique. I found this place on-line years ago and really wanted to try it. Today I had clients that wanted to view a few homes in Sharon Springs. It was the perfect restaurant with professional table service along with quality food options, served without a long wait. If in the area, this is the premiere, go-to, breakfast and lunch. The ride to the area is beautiful. This might even make for a romantic destination spot.
Don't waste your time unless you like bad service and mediocre food.
Great food, good prices, entertaining staff!