Reviews (100)
Passing through. Needed a coffee and a snack. This seemed to be the best place to stop in town. IT WAS!!! Coffee was excellent, and the pastries were superb. Great job. TY
Fantastic cup of coffee with wonderful continental breakfast items. Highly recommend the almond croissant and the monkey bread! Lemon blueberry waffle was a treat!
I rarely leave reviews, but this coffee shop is top notch. Everything is carefully crafted and worth every penny. I would put their coffee up against any brew in Manhattan.
I went here for breakfast earlier today and did not get what I was expecting. I didn't know much about this place just that they were mainly coffee, so when I went here to get breakfast I didn't have high expectations. Got in and it didn't take long to place an order, sit down, and get our drinks. I got just a normal iced tea and my friend got the green pomegranate iced tea. We sat down for a little bit and chatted in the cozy, modern cafe. It didn't take long at all for our food to be brought to our table and the food looked good. The classic waffle is just one waffle cut into fourths, so for 7 dollars a piece you might be able to get more somewhere else. When I first tried the food I was very impressed and shocked that a small cafe could make good food aswell. Aside from the price, which ended up being about $22 for 2 teas and 2 waffles, it was a great experience and I will more than likely return. Most definitely recommend, Nicolas Cage.
Great place for coffee. As a tourist, it was our first option for some coffee in Penn Yan, and didn't disappoint
Mediocre bagel, and slowest moving staff I've ever seen. Coffee was good.
Great service, great vibe, and spacious. I’ll be back.
Great coffe in a quiet peaceful setting
This place is a winner. Great atmosphere, service, lattes, and treats. Can't wait to go back!
Good food and great coffee with a quaint interior
WONDERFUL EXPERIENCE I went to Amity Coffee Co. with my family today. It was our first time in the area and we stumbled upon it passing through. SO GLAD WE STOPPED! The shop has the most welcoming energy and atmosphere. The baristas were very kind and I couldn’t believe how fast our drinks were made. I also cannot believe how perfect my matcha latte tasted. I look forward to coming back again!!!
Always a good coffee experience. My go to errand treat to myself
Love this place. Get breakfast every time we are in Penn Yan
Exactly what a local coffee shop should be - great coffee, amazing food, unbeatably comfy spots to relax, and terrific music. Top that off with a kind staff and you can’t go wrong! I find myself making excuses to come to Penn Yan just to stop in.
Best macaroon. Butter pecan was big and filling creamy
Nice coffee that tastes nutty, we got an Americano and a latte. Place has a good vibe. It was packed on Sunday morning around 9 AM. But this is probably because there aren't many coffee options nearby. Will return when we're in the area.
A ‘must add to the itinerary’ if visiting the Finger Lakes. Come for the coffee, stay for the breakfast. The egg & cheese croissant and the breakfast bowl are both fresh and delicious!! The space is lovely, and busy because of how great it is.
We enjoyed the atmosphere and the staff. Their coffee that they roast was impressive.
Amazing place. The food was absolutely delicious and fresh. The atmosphere is great and spacious. Worth the $.
Cute coffee shop and absolutely massive pastries! Excellent coffee and quick service.