Reviews (77)
Just stopped in for the first time today and I wasn’t disappointed. I just had a decorated sugar cookie and it was pretty amazing. If the rest of the goodies I got are this good I think my waistline is in trouble. 😳😂
This is my favorite bakery
One of the BEST Lunch Specials around. Chicken Salad Sandwich, Roasted Pepper Soup, bag of chips, cookie and a drink!!! I will absolutely return❤️❤️❤️
Purchased some cupcakes and drops for my wife's birthday. We really enjoyed them.. also Purchased a dog treat which my dog loved
Very yummy but they need to advertise to bring customers in so the prices come down.
My husband and I met at a Sea Wolves game so at our wedding we ordered cookies with the mascot on them. They turned out perfect!! Thank you so much! Would recommend for your personalized baked goods.
The gelato was the best I've had anywhere.
Excellent variety of goods. We purchased cake balls, chocolate covered fudge, and numerous types of cookies. Everything was fantastic! The store was clean and well organized and the service was very friendly. It can be a little pricey but did not mind that as everything is made from scratch. If you are looking for top-notch pastries and getting your chocolate fix, this is the place!!!
Had some killa treats at Buffalo Flea, was incredible ❤️
Great selection and great service. Will definitely go back and try a different treat.
Always great. Love everything we've purchased here!!
They made my wife a wonderful and delicious birthday cake! Very friendly staff and fair pricing.
Nice bakery with lots of options and gelato as a bonus :)
The first time I went to Killa was when they first opened. They were pretty good, albeit pricier than most small town bakeries. I chalked it up to ambition and prices would match quality over time. I went Wednesday with my wife and daughter for Gelato and to see what changes have occurred in the last year. The Gelato was delicious, but way overpriced. I also got two peanut butter cupcakes and was highly disappointed. The cake portion was extremely dense and annoyingly dry. The frosting was obnoxiously sweet and dense as well. The price on these was 3.24 each. Not worth it in the least. Couldn't even eat the second one because I felt the density. I get that they are trying to accomplish, but focus on improving existing items. Cupcakes shouldn't be dense and powerfully sweet. I've lived in LA and NY. The most successful shops have light and airy cakes. Won't be returning to Killa.
Great coffee and fantastic homemade cookies! Super cute place and an unexpected joy to find.
This is quite a quaint little bakery. We got chicken salad and egg salad sandwiches, wedding soup, a cookie, a drink, and a cupcake for a very reasonable price. Friendly staff and the bakery items look delicious! We'll be returning.
Finally was able to catch them open! Bought lots of stuff. Cookies were good, brownie and marshmallow treats were amazing, loved the gelato. The only not so great was the cupcake...pretty dry. Would be 5 star hands down with moister cupcakes. Will be back for more yums!
My niece bought a cake for a birthday party and it was the worst cake ! $80+ for a small three tier white cake, way too much frosting and dry white cake. What a ripoff! It had very little to do with the look of the cake but everything to do with the taste and texture of the cake.
Even when you first walk in the smell is so wonderful. They have an amazing assortment of flavors from cupcakes, cookies, cake balls and many other treats. They also have gluten free options. I had cupcakes, cookies and a cake made from Almond flour for my wedding and they were fantastic!
I was FORTUNATE to delve into the Killa Kookies and Kream delights this past weekend at the Rochester Psychic Fair. Their table was the FIRST table I saw and I couldn't be HAPPIER! I loaded up on MANY, MANY treats! I am in LOVE with the Almond Raspberry Shortbread YUMMY desert and the peanut butter cookies were the BEST I've had in YEARS!!! OMG - SOOOO good!!! The ARRAY of cake ball flavors was AWESOME and they are DE-LISH!! Thank you VERY much to the two people working the table, too as they were AWESOME!! I only wish I lived in Jamestown, now! I would be a FREQUENT FLYER!! :-)