Reviews (100)
Under new ownership. Great coffee great atmosphere!
One of my fav coffee places!!! Cute atmosphere & friendly staff
We will stop in after a bike ride for coffee nice place great people
If you want to go somewhere that everybody knows your name, come to Coffee Potter. It's an incredibly warm environment where the baristas get to know you and your kiddos. Love this place.
Love The Coffee Potter - I go out of my way to shop here. Coffee is excellent (especially love the raspberry crumb cake). Would highly recommend!
It ended up being a great option for an afternoon coffee and a little cute place to work in. The place is very comfortable and the staff is surprisingly young, yet extremely serviceable, polite and professional. Definitely recommend it and will be coming repeatedly during my time in Long Valley.
If you like burnt cold brew this is the place for you. So nasty. I've tried this place a few times and I always have high hopes and it always disappoints.
Great folks with really nice coffee and food options. Seating area is comfy and vibrant.
Bustling coffee with fresh snacking of all kinds. Cheerful staff and chillaxed atmosphere. Lovely wood detail and preserved historical ambiance. Busy weekend drive-thru and ample parking. Super convenient to Columbia trail and historic sites.
Drive thru line was packed! Saturday 11am. We went inside, nice places to sit, nice people working there, had a scone and Americano. Great place, it’s worth the wait
Good drinks, and the best service. The drinks are always on point and the pupachinos our two boerboels absolutely go crazy for after a walk on the Columbia trail.
The variety of drinks and ready made snacks is impressive. Very friendly staff! Dining in, however, is challenging. Perhaps it's a matter of timing? Every time I've stopped by, the tables are occupied by people with laptops - who appear to camp out for long periods of time. The small sitting room is very nice. But always occupied as well.
The best coffee place!! My favorite!
Cozy coffee shop. Lavender latte and hot chocolate were good. Has plenty of seating and a drive through.
I can't recommend The Coffee Potter enough - it's a fantastic coffee shop with great drinks, food, and atmosphere, and it's clear that the owners and staff really care about providing a top-notch experience for their customers. It's a true gem in the local coffee scene, and I'll be coming back here again and again.
Excellent coffee chain alternative. Egg, cheese, quinoa wrap is delicious and satisfying especially when warmed up. Scones are top notch.
Everyone is always super friendly, the drinks are made with care and quality ingredients. Parking can be difficult at times but this is only due to their popularity and not due to lack of parking. This is a cute coffee spot. Seating around the perimeter has outlets to accommodate your devices if you are hanging out and doing work while you drink your coffee or other hot beverage. Nice days, I encourage you to park at the trail and walk while enjoying your drink.
My favorite coffee shop in the area.
cute coffee shop that is bustling! there's sit down inside, seating outside, and a drivethru. the dessert case is stocked with goodies. prepare to wait on the weekend, but the staff's friendly and the wait is pleasant
I am very unhappy with my experience at the coffee potter. Only 1 out of the 3 times I’ve been here has the coffee been good. I don’t know what the issue is but my guess is a lack of training. The second time I went my boyfriend and I ordered two lattes and instead got two cups of milk. When he went back to ask for another shot of espresso since our drinks were so pale, the employee said that they can but when people ask for an extra shot it is usually of cold brew. She also charged him extra for the shots. The first photo is our original drinks from this second time. We just now decided to try it again and are just as disappointed. The second photo attached was an order of cold brew with a splash of milk and the other was a vanilla latte. I understand that a latte is mostly milk but the ratio 1 part espresso to 3 parts milk should be followed throughout changes of the cup size. I have never received a latte this pale. And that still doesn't explain why the cold brew with a splash of milk is just as pale as the latte.