Reviews (100)
The food was okay at shetlers. We were having the salad and soup bar Saturday evening around 6. The problem is the soup looked like it had been sitting around since lunchtime. Although it tasted okay it wasn't particularly warm which was a concern for bacteria growth. One of the soup urns was just about empty. A few of the items on the salad bar were empty. There was only iceberg lettuce for the salad. The service was excellent. The acoustics in the restaurant make it difficult to have a pleasant meal with conversation.
Wow, this food was INCREDIBLE and so affordable! The homemade cheddar bread is a MUST.
Great service, food was homemade! Good prices!
What an unexpected surprise! This has to be one of the best burgers I've ever had! Try the Signature Melt, you will not be disappointed. The toasty cheddar bread with melted cheese and a perfectly cooked hamburger with fried jalapenos and onions is fantastic! You will not be disappointed.
awesome food, great prices, friendly staff.
The cafe is a great place to eat and visit. But they need to bring the bar back and their food is so salty they r going to give someone a heart attack.They also need a bigger menu.
Sells rotten food.
Shetler's has a fresh, well kept salad bar- which I can't resist. Our family loves to eat here. The Shetlers Signature burger is a favorite of my husband's. The honey BBQ wings are wonderful! And the Garlic Parmesan. Definitely recommend eating here- it has a cozy atmosphere on a winter day.
Incredible food! Bbq burger is amazing. Good prices great atmosphere.
Food was very good. Ate there twice this week.
Remodeled and looking good! Such a fresh salad bar and delicious food. The staff was very accommodating and we had a great lunch.
Good delicious meal. Home baked hamburger buns are 👌 keep up the good work. Thanks for the meal.
Mushroom burger with sweet potato fries!! Delicious! ☆☆☆☆☆
We had lunch today for the first time since the remodel. Didn't mind so much about the smaller menu but the cashier behind the counter was really rude when we asked her questions. We ordered the special and it came out everything was lukewarm and kind of bland it was a disappointment I can't see it's going back which is a shame because we used to go at least twice or three times a month.
So bummed about the new menu & renovations. This was our go-to place to eat and the buffet was amazing. Lunch menu was all fried food, like an overpriced McDonald's. The new decor even looks like McDonald's it totally lost its amish charm. Very upsetting probably won't be going back
The service was great, we got our food extremely quick and we enjoyed our food. The only complaint I have is the menu is smaller but the food was still good
This cafe use to be very good they had a great buffet and salad bar and desert bar me and my family use to eat here several times a week and they had great service. Not anymore they no longer have the buffet or servers serving you its self serve you have to order at the counter what a shame and they're small tv menu on the wall was a small fraction of what they use to serve. They have completely lost our families loyalty.
Drove 45 miles to get there . Short menue and said no buffet anymore
They changed their menu. Not many items on it. Salad bar is $9. Even if you buy a $10 meal and want to add one trip salad bar on it, $9 for that one trip to the salad bar. BECAUSE THEY WILL NOT DO SALAD BAR AS A “ONE TRIP” ADD ON, AND REQUIRE YOU PAY THE ALL YOU CAN EAT PRICE EVEN THOUGH YOU ONLY WANT ONE SMALL PLATE OF SALAD. The only way they have any vegetables as a side is if it happens to be the vegetable with the special that day. So they’re making eat healthy there impossible unless you are ready to pay $15+
They took out the Friday Buffet and now charge $9 for a salad bar add on. Seriously? $9 add on even if you buy an entree.