Reviews (100)
The staff! Aces! Unfortunately, they only serve lunch, no breakfast! Fresh cakes!
BIG, BIG SHOUT OUT to Cottage Cafe!!! Susie and her staff are absolutely amazing! I called Susie on Thursday to see if she could make an oreo birthday cake that our son requested. She did absolutely an amazing job on such short notice. Cottage Cafe will be my go to for our birthday cakes for now on! It’s homemade from scratch with real whipping cream. It’s huge and so moist - I can go on and on. If you haven’t visited Cottage Cafe in downtown old Middletown go. Thank you Susie! ❤️
Love this cafe! Best salads, hot browns and desserts.
How refreshing and tasty. Also kudos to the nicest attentive staff. This place is everything awesome and then some!
We love eating at Cottage Cafe. The food is home-made and always delicious. The staff members are helpful and friendly. The desserts are a real treat!
Enjoy the food and staff. Great for a ladies lunch. Chairs aren't the most comfortable.
Great burger and deviled eggs! And Omgosh that Ebony and Ivory cake!😋😋😋
Great environment. Friendly faces. Deserts are to die for. They have specials every day of the week.
The food and service were excellent. Definitely worth a stop for lunch and a slice of cake.
The food was great and their homade made spread for my sandwich was outstanding. Make sure you get a dessert.
Very cute cafe! The service is very friendly and fast. Huge portions of food for very reasonable prices.
Delicious food and plenty of it!! Got chicken salad, so good and the cakes were so scrumptious. Will be back!! Everyone friendly, like being at a family gathering. Alicia is so sweet!!!
Absolutely love this little place and the owner, Susan, and her staff, are quite wonderful. Service is fast and attentive and portion sizes are large. Quality of food is excellent, and desserts are what they're known for. And they go out of their way to employ special needs adults.
As always, food great and very fresh. The best part is the deserts. Made fresh daily with an add in of Susan's TLC. Oh yes, Donna sassy as ever.
Nice little lunch place for a good, home cooked meal. Had the tuna melt, which was served open-faced with a slice of Provolone and a slice of American cheese. My friend had the Benedictine sandwich, which she said was good. Didn't skimp on the Benedictine.
Been dining here over 20 years and always have excellent food, friendly service, and fun atmosphere.
Always friendly. Always delicious food. And the desserts... there's a reason they display them in case you see as you enter the restaurant. They are the biggest appeal of all. The portions are huge! Pro tip - order dessert before you order your food. It might run out if you wait until after you finish your meal.
Best chicken salad anywhere. Great broccoli cheese soup, too.
Delicious tomato basil soup & chicken salad on croissant! Always delicious, homemade cakes & pies!!! Good service as well:) The baby bleu salad is Delicious!!!
What a comfy spot for lunch So friendly and good food definitely will be making a return trip