Reviews (100)
Five Star all around
Quite busy on a Monday at 11:45, I enjoyed the lime freeze and took a turkey Rueben to go due to the time it took to prepare. Plenty of memorabilia and people watching to keep myself entertained. The drink and sandwich were great.
Absolutely slaps 👏 🔥 🙌 👌 💯 and good people the guy at the register was very inviting shared some history definitely will be heading back there
Total vintage café, milkshakes,and friendly service... if you go there 4 or 5 times, they'll remember your drink orders and names. I love their salads, and their milkshakes are amazing too
You're treated like family here and that's always appreciated. Food was fantastic today, I recommend the Chubby Checker to everyone.
This is such a great place ,,,,, and it does take you a step back
Our local friends recommended that we experience Traditions. They specifically recommended the lime sherbet freeze soda. It was fantastic! This place is adorable - a throwback to the 50s. Mike, the owner was there, and told us about the diner’s history. As we sat at the old time bar, we also split a roast beef and gravy sandwich- a true comfort, to-die-for experience. The malts are creamy and delicious as well. The entire staff was warm, friendly, and seemed truly excited that we had come to experience Traditions and Garden City. We would highly recommend stopping by to dine in!
Delicious sandwiches. One of the better shakes I’ve had. Affordable prices. Very friendly staff.
Great service food is always amazing
Food and service are always good there. Took 2 friends who had never eaten in there before. They loved it.
Had a wonderful lunch at this great spot! The owners were so friendly and the food was affordable and delicious! Happy hour ice cream was a bonus!
Great food and atmosphere!
Tired it again for the second time ,both times waited and waited for service and nothing. Walked out again Will not be trying that place no more 👎🏽
Best burger I've had! Try the limeade!
I haven't eaten here since I was a kid. I ordered the lime freeze and was transported back to my youth. The 1950s atmosphere is exactly what you'd want it to be in a eatery like this. The prices are fair and the selection widespread. I'd thoroughly recommend stopping by here. Next time, I'm ordering a lemon shake. Update, I went back and ordered the lemon shake. Perfection. I also ordered the Chubby Checker. That paired nicely with the shake.
Great place to frequent. Quality food at affordable prices.
Beat place to eat a good meal. There pies are so good always get a slice after done eating.
My favorite place to eat🥰 the sweetest owners ever so kind and caring. They make sure you love your drinks and food❤ couldn't recommend this place more. I always get the daily potato soup and the big bopper. Litteraly so yummy
We both had the Big Bopper! THE sandwich to have! Our first visit and we hope to be back! Try the Lime Freeze!!
Traditions always has great sandwiches, pies and ice cream. I recommend getting the Big Bopper sandwich. Roast beef, ham, cheese and grilled onions with BBQ sauce. Absolutely delicious.