Real Coffee Club
DeliDeli

Katz’s New York Deli

★★★★☆ 4.2/5 (100 reviews)
32 Toccoa Ave, McCaysville, GA 30555 (423) 443-1636 Website
Katz’s New York Deli Katz’s New York Deli Katz’s New York Deli Katz’s New York Deli Katz’s New York Deli

Reviews (100)

C
Christie Norris
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

What a treasure.. we had the pleasure of dining for breakfast and it was Devine! If you have the chance while passing through defiantly stop!

B
Brad Rubini
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Good food, fair prices and fast service. When getting off the train cross the street and go left

S
Steve Rahm
★★★☆☆ Jan 20, 1970

Great potential and it felt like it works be a personal luxury. It was fine but order at counter service, request for tip right up front, and food was fine but not exceptional.. Take dune chances. I'd recommend it to anyone in the area or passing through and probably not go out of my way. It's a great little building with major potential.

E
Erica Scott
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Oh y’all! We got bacon egg and cheese biscuits, biscuits and gravy, and a chicken and egg biscuit for brunch. All of it was amazing!! And the place is so cute and homey, and everyone was so nice. Will definitely stop here again if we’re ever up this way!!

C
Chris
★☆☆☆☆ Jan 20, 1970

Drove out of the way to eat here and they're closed at 10am on a Thursday. 🤦🏻

E
Evangeline Zamm- Realtor (Luxury, Vacation Homes)
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Cute place! Great sandwiches….. stop in for a nice coffee or dessert

W
Will Hudson
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Great spot for a quick breakfast, coffee or something sweet in a nice little town on the border of Georgia and Tennessee. Very friendly people working and nice locals.

R
Rick McFall
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Wonderful experience. Food was very tasty and fulfilling. Service was top notch. Pricing was as expected.

T
Todd Watkins
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Great little place to eat. Staff extremely friendly. Cool little place, as it looks like a converted very old house. Food was good.

J
Justin L
★☆☆☆☆ Jan 20, 1970

I would avoid this place at all costs. Totally rude staff and owner Nancy. My friend lives with me and has gone here for few weeks. We are locals and apparently you get locals discount. We did not know this till I accompanied her to the coffee shop. I had other friends visit from Florida who asked to substitute meat in the breakfast sandwich for spinach and Nancy overcharged them like 8 more dollars to add spinach. Today is the final straw my friend goes in to get us drinks and they are rolling their eyes and acting rude. We will never be returning. The only reason they are acting so rude I assume is that my friend has an accent and my friends from Florida are from India and are not White. You should be ashamed of yourself Nancy and employees.

M
Melissa ..
★☆☆☆☆ Jan 20, 1970

Not like a “NY deli” in any way. I’m super sad because I had high hopes of spending a lot of money here if it was like real egg sandwiches.. or good coffee.. or speed.

T
Todd Rarick
★★★☆☆ Jan 20, 1970

Cute little place. The staff is very nice. I went with chicken, egg with sausage gravy special. It was a little pricey at $13 but the staff sold me on it. The biscuit was good, the chicken was a microwave chicken breast. I think I should have stuck with something basic.

H
Heck Yeah
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

This is a gem. Excellent service AND food. Great atmosphere. I would recommend this place to anyone based off my first visit! Edit: I've been here several times now and I must say, this place is consistent and the service is quick.

L
L. Lovegood
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Absolutely delicious! I ordered an ice chai latte and an everything bagel with scrambled eggs, cheese, and sausage. It was a 10/10! Great place :)

H
Heidi Herzog
★☆☆☆☆ Jan 20, 1970

Mediocre at best For breakfast I ordered an omelette it came with 1 piece of toast and no sides for $14.00 for a 2 egg omelette! This tiny omelette had very little tomato and very little spinach with a little bit of cheese sprinkled on top… definitely not the best breakfast in town. I ordered a glass of water with lemon and I had to buy bottle of water my husband ordered ice tea he had to buy a bottle of ice tea… my husband‘s pastrami sandwich was lacking the same as my omelette. For mustard and mayonnaise you used packets that are on a nearby counter. Seriously the food is lacking any pizzazz at all You order upfront and they give you a buzzer when your foods ready that you have to go pick up. I definitely won’t return and I would suggest you find somewhere else to eat

A
aj sweedler and mario jvs
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

A quaint, cozy house transformed into a delicious deli/restaurant. The employees are friendly and welcoming. The place is casual and relaxing. You head in the front door to a restaurant setting in a living room and head to the right to find a Deli counter with baked goods and more. You're greeted and look up at a bulletin board/chalkboard style menu hanging, place your order and pay for your purchase. You are invited to grab an available table inside or out. My sandwich was delicious. It was good sized, too. I admit, I ate the whole thing. Yummmm.

N
Nick Gonzalez
★★★☆☆ Jan 20, 1970

I was excited to find a local breakfast spot. Turns out it's just a tourist trap w overpriced food. I wasn't impressed with the heavily taxed corn beef hash out of a can.

L
Laura Anderson
★★★☆☆ Jan 20, 1970

Sandwiches were ok, but the price was outrageous. I was super excited that they had GF bread, but their Reuben was lacking. Corned beef was lean,but had no flavour and 1,000 island was way too sweet. Won't be going back for those prices. $15 for a Reuben is a little steep.

T
Tonya Caye
★★★★★ Jan 20, 1970

Such a charming place. Wonderful, friendly service, and the food was great! We had breakfast at our visit and it was delicious.

T
Teresa Rivera
★☆☆☆☆ Jan 20, 1970

The menu looked promising although the sandwiches were around $15. The pbj was $7. Obviously, we showed up at a busy time because all the older lady cashier could say was “I’ve been here since 7am” and kept telling waiting customers they couldn’t stand and wait. She literally ran us off and we had nowhere to sit. Even if they didn’t expect others to be closed today, you would think they would be stocked. They were out of lots of menu items and places to sit. You would think a packed house would be a good thing for a business but she was obviously frustrated and rude. Saying “I’m not trying to be rude” doesn’t make a bad attitude not rude. We were told 20 mins and it was well over 30 mins. They were out of corn beef hash so I had to get pastrami. It was okay but not tender, covered in a purple slaw, and had a thousand island tasting sauce. I guess I was expecting a real rueben with at least swiss and sauerkraut.