Reviews (100)
Delicious key lime pie! We even bought their key lime cookies as gifts for family and friends. Beautiful outdoor seating with a relaxing vibe. A lizard even kept us company as we ate.
Pie was excellent! Price was consistent with other areas selling key lime pie.
These pies are incredible!!! Split two slices with my wife the Chocolate Key lime and the traditional meringue….liked them both….will definitely be going back. Also the lock garden was really neat!
The key lime meringue pie is incredible. We tried that one and the chocolate, the meringue was so good we shared a second slice. Coffee is great also, and comes with a little key lime cookie, nice touch. The lounge area is a calming place to enjoy your dessert.
Delicious key lime pies but super pricy. Don't be shocked when you check out.
Best Key Lime pie in the business. The Naked is what most people know, but the Meringue is the most authentic.
Best key lime pie I’ve ever tasted in my life! I loved the ambiance. Definitely worth stopping at! We’ll be back next time we’re in the Florida Keys!
Best key lime pie throughout the keys. The outdoor seating is very nice and peaceful.
Most delicious and amazing key lime pie!! Yumm!!!! Plus beautiful outdoor seating area
The key lime pie wasn’t the best we’ve had, but the Love Garden was worth the visit. Definitely stop here.
Best Key Lime Pie in the Florida Keys. We came up from Key West just to get Key Lime Pie here. I love the one with meringue one top and my husband gets the one dipped in chocolate. If we are in any of the Keys this is always a stop for us.
If you are looking for Key Lime Pie, look no further. This is the spot you have been looking for! I had the chocolate covered pie and it was fantastic. My girlfriend had the regular key lime pie and she said it was the best she's ever had. Id have to agree with that sentiment. We also got key lime cookies to go which are delicious to say the least. GO, you will not be disappointed!
The pie is good here. It’s our second time stopping by over the past few years. This time we had our two young kids with us. The first thing we noticed is all of the passive aggressive signage for various things. No pets allowed. Fine. Pretty normal policy for an eating establishment. But “do not try to pass off your pet as a service animal. You ruin it for everyone else!..” and “DO NOT EAT HERE! This is a coffee bar!” And “NO CASH! We have the right to set our own payment policy..blah blah blah..” and “You are entering a quiet zone!!” On a giant sign before you enter the outdoor area. The girl that rang us up was sure to tell us (quite rudely) that the outdoor are was “a lovely garden, NOT a play area.” We had no intentions of letting our kids run feral outside. The comment was just super off-putting and unwelcoming. What business in a vacation destination bans children? Insane. The pie is fine, but for a better experience go literally anywhere else. Much better places in the Keys.
The famous key lime pie, frozen Pie on a Stick and Key Lime Cookies were pretty good.
We started early morning our journey to keywest and we luckily found this factory on way and this was just amazing place. Glad we stopped to taste the best key lime pie . Freshly made. We tried 2 flavors chocolate and the plain. Both were good. Perfect blend of lime and sweetness. The ambiance is really good. I loved the restaurant area they made. Very beautifully decorated. Loved it.
Yeah, that Key Lime Pie dipped in chocolate frozen pop is a thing. I’m so glad I got that as the appetizer to the main course meringue key lime pie. So good! There is also a peaceful shaded spacious garden with seating to enjoy.
The best key lime pie I’ve had! Nice little shop, got some key lime taffy! Delicious!
Here’s the thing, I don’t like pie but this key lime pie is maybe one of the best things I’ve ever eaten… that’s a bold statement for me. The chocolate dipped on a stick was incredible as well as the key lime with meringue. The outdoor garden in back is lovely to sit and eat. They have tons of other snacks and treats, key lime flavored. An absolute must try!! Update: came back for a second time and it’s truly the best key lime pie in all of the keys. I tried a lot of pie while in the keys and this is the best place by far.
Just okay. It lacks that key lime pie tartness. Also pretty pricey at 7.50 a slice. Not sure how but Kermit's on Duval St in key west was less expensive. Seating area is amazing.
Beautiful garden to enjoy eating a key lime pastry...pie, cookie or frozen pie on a stick.