Nana Teresa's Bake Shop

Cream puffs taste like it’s filled will Walmart cake icing. A bit disappointing tbh.

First of all, thank you for being open on Monday! It's unbelievably difficult to find a place to get great coffee and pastries on a Monday, when you need them most 😂 Anyway, this place is wonderful! The delightful human that greeted us was helpful and adeptly explained the menu. She described one of the pastries as a "religious experience" and I told her we could definitely be friends. She was also not wrong. I was deeply moved by the caramelized dough and felt closer to my Creator. 😅🥐 Overall, an excellent experience! We will absolutely return.

In my opinion the pies have been frozen. I had a lemon merainge pie and it had the freezer burn taste. Just my opinion. The crust was not flacky and fresh.

Best tres leches cake I've ever tasted. It's a A+. Great Bakery!!

Lovely little bake shop! We wanted to sample everything! We went on my wife's birthday and they lit a candle on her cupcake for her birthday!

Best pastries and coffee in town. We encouraged Mark, the owner, to open a store in Sarasota.

I can only speak for the cupcakes, but I did not enjoy them at all. Both the cake texture & the cream taste were just off. Another star added because there was quite a selection, so maybe those other things were better

Friendly service and excellent pastries. We tried the key lime cream puff and key lime tarts. Both were exceptional, however, I would recommend you come during the week for the freshest baked goods (when the baker is working). The key lime cream puff was slightly stale when we bought it on the weekend, but it was still delicious and not bad enough to stop us from coming by again.

Very low stock when we went. Only cupcakes and macarons available. Macarons were good though.

The first day it was cupcakes; the second day it was cheesecake; the third day a latte and cinnamon bun. This bakery is one of the best ever! And the staff was very welcoming. I am going to visit once more before heading home. Thanks very much for your scrumptious goodies!!!👍😀

Very friendly people. Not sure if they were the owners but helpful and great experience. 1st time. Thank you!

Very yummy pastries and friendly staff. We have been there 3 times in 5 days because we want to try a little of everything.

This chocolate chip cookie is amazing. Melted and so much chocolate! I’ve been trying to find a local place closer to me that compares but they don’t. So when I’m in the area, I make sure to go. Looking to take a trip there soon for it 😋

Placed a last minute Thanksgiving order and didn't think they were going to be able to accommodate the request. Immediately got an email from Teresa and she said they would do their best. And, they did! Great service, great communication and our Fernandina office LOVED the treats. Thank you so much!!!!

I tried the mango boba tea and OH MY! My new favorite drink! I got a piece of cherry cheesecake, a banana pudding cupcake and a lemon cupcake and they were the best tasting desserts I think I’ve ever had! 11/10 recommended!!!!!! Good job you guys!!!

Absolutely fantastic experience with this business. I have ordered several cakes from them and they are my new go to. They do a beautiful job and the customer service is wonderful. So accommodating and flexible. Everybody is always so impressed by the cakes. Really a gem of a place.

I come here when I can, absolutely awesome treats and coffee! Come here and get your breakfast for the next morning - best idea! They give military discount too, Thanks

We love this place....so good even, the locals go here.

Nice place, very good treats. Ordered Coconut cake. It was good. I'm used to a little more coconut on the cake. Overall nice shop. Tourist and Locals like it.

Best, fresh whoopie pie (a smore variation) on the planet! Something different and delicious every day. We stopped in 2 times today (morning and evening)! This is a taste bud delight!!