Reviews (100)
Fresh and soooo good
The folks in this place are not the friendliest, but we love this restaurant's bagels. We have tried almost all of the bagel flavors. They are all delicious!
It was absolutely amazing. Fresh, delicious and fast. Service is impeccable - such a nice people. We found it by chance, but it exceeded our expectation! 🤩 P.S. The peach smoothie was more than delicious, one of the best I have ever had. 🍑
Best breakfast or lunch in the entire FL keys. Don't miss it!
Love this small sandwich shop. Super friendly service and coffee was great the omelette was top notch! Would definitely recommend.
Excellent food created by excellent people!
Great food, friendly environment, wonderful people working there, and lovely rooster.
Great food
Delicious food and great service! Highly recommend giving this place a try.
Best breakfast in Big Pine Key
Hate to give this place this score since I had researched it and saved it for a visit before we even got here. But...the bagels were awful. No flavor. Ordered several kinds, so it wasn't just one choice or flavor. We ordered a Cuban sandwich, but we got a sandwich made with salami and American cheese, and no pickles. You're 120 miles from Cuba. How could you mess that sandwich up so badly? For the record: It's ham, turkey, pork, Swiss, mustard and pickles on Cuban bread. Anyway, that's my honest review. I won't be back, and you shouldn't go either if you want a good bagel or a good Cuban sandwich. (Didn't eat anything else here.)
Always friendly and great service definitely a morning stop for locals and vacationing guest it's convenient and delicious
Good food, fresh bagels, and friendly owners!
Best bagels ever! Wien going back from Key West we’ll definitely stop to buy bagels again
Went there for coffee every morning while we were there.
Food was good, the coffee was OK, by 11 am already not too hot and scarce. This place is clean, and the staff is good.
AFFORDABLE AND DELICIOUS! One of the best places to go to eat in the keys :)
While driving to Key West we were getting some pictures of the Key Deer in the area. Found Bagel Island by accident and decided to try it. Very good food and service.
Cute mom and pop shop, super friendly staff and delicious items ✨
Small but food was good. The owners very nice and personable with all their customers. Definitely will go back.