Search

Amenities

  • Outdoor seating
  • Takeout

Marty's Mercantile Reviews - 100

5
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Myron Cohen

excellent Burger!!Friendly owner and staff!Jane's Ice-cream for desert...really wish it was open more!Music Garden and Bandstand are behind The Place..A great local place closeby!

Jorge Camuñas

Delicious Vegan and non-vegan sandwiches. Excellent service. Friendly atmosphere. A short bike ride away from the Ashokan Rail Trail

david zimel

Small place comfortable great music seriously great music and the food food's marvelous you served and cooked by people who care what they're doing they even commented on the avocado relish with onion and found out that the waitress had made it and snuck some pepper in and I'm glad she did if you're nearby stop in you won't regret it

Amanda Miller

Stopped here on our way home from Hunter mountain. Quaint and tasty cafe. We loved the Deviled Egg sandwich. The Taylor Ham is sliced really thin... delicious!

I also recommend a slice of the carrot cake if they have it. Absolutely incredible.

Julia Wilkerson

Great coffee, friendly service and some of the best sandwiches we had all week! Highly recommend the Lumberjack and the chicken sandwich on the lunch menu. If it’s nice out, grab a beer or two and enjoy your meal in the spacious backyard.

Carol Lee

Super cute place. Great focused menu for breakfast and lunch but definitely has enough variety to make sure there's something for everyone. We went for breakfast and I had the Mexicali Blues wrap and added some breakfast sausage. Perfect breakfast! Cold brew was on point (thanks Java Love). A really great new place on 28A and if you're coming up from NYC, and don't REALLY feel like going to Phoenicia Diner for the thousandth time, definitely stop by here for breakfast/lunch. Employees are very friendly. We'll be back for sure!! Thanks guys!

Safat Hossain

Amazing place and great setup. Everything locally sourced. Really good food and the cook is amazing. A shoutout to ma man Louis, for being such a great cook and host!! Lou - can’t wait to hangout and try more food again!!

Karianna Haasch

Genuine good food made by great people. Everything is made with locally sourced ingredients, plus a great selection of local craft beers and local handmade gifts. Beautiful backyard seating area with picnic tables and a fire pit. This place is worth a trip to West Shokan!

April Lecato

Came here super hungry after a hike along the reservoir, and Marty’s sandwiches hit the spot. Perfect turkey club with a surprise pickle on the side, that was a delight. Really nice people behind the counter too. Will be back soon!

Liz Potter

A very special breakfast, lunch and community place. I've savored each of the sandwiches I've had at this cozy neighborhood cafe (with outdoor seating and great staff). And today I had a meeting catered. Planning took no time texting with the owners and the menu they suggested (fresh veggie hero, fruit salad with lime dressing) was so tasty. Everything was flawless and professional. Thank you!

Add Review

Cleanliness
Comfort
Staff
Facilities
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload