Black Cat

The steak sandwich is the world's best, if available. The breakfast potatoes were great as well. Actually, all the food at our table was exceptional and unique.
I found this place on-line years ago and really wanted to try it. Today I had clients that wanted to view a few homes in Sharon Springs. It was the perfect restaurant with professional table service along with quality food options, served without a long wait.
If in the area, this is the premiere, go-to, breakfast and lunch. The ride to the area is beautiful. This might even make for a romantic destination spot.

I just loved the Cassandra club and the goat cheese Mac and cheese and it's all great prices

Stopped in while visiting the area for quick lunch today. Decor is wonderfully funky, menu is small and limited. My friend and I both got the special - a grilled cheese with hot sauce and bacon. Was delicious. The cookies were got for dessert were also delicious (and massive). Service was pretty quick.

This place is awesome! We visited Sharon Springs out of season, and I think we were the only non locals dining. The staff was great, the owner was friendly and made a point to come ask about our meal, which I love. I accidentally left my ID there- when I called and they couldn't initially find it they went out of their way to search for it, talking to me all the while and making it kind of fun, actually. We would never eat anywhere else when visiting Sharon Springs in the future

It is a very charming cafe. Food was good. Staff was not attentive and pretty erratic. For the prices the presentation left a great deal to be desired. Three of us ordered sandwiches that were unceremoniously placed in front of the wrong people... plated were... the sandwiches. No sides, no 'pretty' ... just sandwiches. Order taken by owner who was completely distracted while we were ordering. Watched as a couple near us got their order in increments and, once again, plopped on the table as the waitress immediately fled. For a $40 plus bill this was a somewhat unsatisfying lunch at a venue that COULD have been 90% better. We will NOT be recommending this place to any of our friends. We also ordered iced teas .. at $3 a pop....maybe 5 tiny ice cubes and drinks were pretty much room temperature.

Atmosphere and service were good, but the food was disappointing. Corned beef sandwich was no comparison to a favorite from a Schenectady deli. Cider donuts were hard, bitter, and bone-dry. Plus actual dirt in a salad's poorly rinsed lettuce. Shame because the place was charming.

Food was great when I went here. Had the Thanksgiving Day sandwich and the turkey and stuffing was delightful to say the least. The waitress was new so there were a few hiccups in getting our food but she was beyond kind so I totally understood. I'd gladly come back here and have the same thing again!

Beware the Fig-Balsamic Truffles. I bought some at their stand at the Cooperstown Farmers Market. First of all, please price your items. I picked these up to look at them and the woman said, "That'll be $13." Well, I didn't feel like I could put them back down, so I shelled out 13 hard-earned dollars for the box of four and prayed they were as delicious as they sounded. Well, they are not. Far from it. The balsamic used is not a sweet, aged variety. It is sharp and totally overwhelms. You wouldn't know there was chocolate or fig in these. They would be better suited as a topping for a green salad than as a dessert. But who wants a $13 crouton?

The. Worst. Ordered a lemonade & iced herbal tea. The employee tamped down the ice in my glass with the palm of her hand.

It was a Fantastic lunch as Always! Tony and his crew are great! Thank you for all you do! ❤️