Amity Coffee Co.

This little shop was recommended to me by fellow campers and it was just as they described! We've come back everyday since. The iced caramel latte was absolutely perfect and they made it exactly how I asked of them. It's a small space but perfect for the small hometown feel to grab and go, or sit and chat. Definently a gem in this town! Blessings for many more successful years!

Always make sure to go (usually multiple times, let’s be honest) when I’m home. The kindest humans work there, their cold brew is perfect, and the store itself is a labor of love. Penn Yan is lucky to have such a beautiful, make you feel at home space.

Wow this place is always amazing. Great service, drinks & baked goods. Interior makes me feel like I’m back in the city. Thanks Amity!

We enjoyed the atmosphere and the staff. Their coffee that they roast was impressive.

The caramel latte, banana scone and lemon cookie was delicious!! And the staff was sweet as well. Overall, a very nice spot right in town!

Amazing place. The food was absolutely delicious and fresh. The atmosphere is great and spacious. Worth the $.

Absolutely the worst coffee I've ever wasted money on. Literally had to pour it out. The employee didn't make you feel welcome. If you enjoy coffee and have taste I wouldn't recommend it. First impressions go a long way with me. I've tried 2 speciality coffee shops in the town so far and have been disappointed so far. I may have my standards set to high.

The coffee was really good. I love lattes and I’m always on a hunt for good coffee. Amity coffee did not disappoint, if I’m in the area again, will definitely stop by.

Good food and great coffee with a quaint interior

Beside having standard coffee options, Amity has a small but unique breakfast menu. I tried the waffle with Sriracha, honey, cheddar, bacon, and cilantro. I've never had anything like it before and it was good (and spicy)! They also had more "normal" breakfast options such as a classic waffle, bagels, and pastries.