Amity Coffee Co.

Excellent staff and coffee. Friendly place with good space. Now that summer is almost here, it's getting busier and busier. Now located at 3 main street not 13. Still quiet in the afternoon.

Fantastic cup of coffee with wonderful continental breakfast items. Highly recommend the almond croissant and the monkey bread! Lemon blueberry waffle was a treat!

I rarely leave reviews, but this coffee shop is top notch. Everything is carefully crafted and worth every penny. I would put their coffee up against any brew in Manhattan.

This place is a gem in an up and coming town. The vibe is eclectic cozy boutique. The coffee is incredible, the baristas know what they’re doing, and the food options (while limited) are just as great as their coffee. They offer daily and seasonal items as well as a variety of pastries and baked goods outside of their food selection. They have a cool gathering space towards the back of the shop with reading materials and board games available for play. They also have free wifi for anyone looking to set up a remote office for the day. If Amity Coffee Co. is a sign of things coming to Penn Yan, then I am very excited for this warm and rustic town.

Favorite place in town to grab a custom coffee and egg breakfast sandwich. They just moved to a new location and it's great. One of the few places like this that I actually own merchandise from if that tells you anything. Staff is very friendly.

Love the atmosphere, food was really good and strong coffee. They had board games to pass the time .

Very nice little coffee shop, worth a stop when in the area. I got a pour over with an Ethiopian coffee which was good. We also bought a couple of scones. The scones were delicious and the other baked goods in the cabinet were very tempting. We would return the next time we are in the area.

Cute coffee shop and absolutely massive pastries! Excellent coffee and quick service.

Didn’t get many pictures unfortunately because this place is really pretty and modern. I also really enjoyed the coffee I drank. What I did NOT enjoy was the rude girl who took my order. I asked her questions about the drink I was going to order and she laughed and responded in a rude sarcastic way and gave rude looks as if I was annoying her with my presence. 0/5 for customer service, do better. I really wanted to rate higher but I think the people who work there and build relationships with the customers are equally important.

Quaint little coffee shop in the heart of downtown Penn Yan. Good coffee, coffee drinks, and tea. Nice small selection of food items as well. Staff was wonderful.