Cafe Sarah

Really friendly service and the best baked goods in Hamilton County. I always stop by when I'm on my way to visit my Mom in Indian Lake.

Delicious scones! Everything else is most likely great too, but I just keep getting the scones because they're awesome!

Bery friendly people in this cafe, and in the village in general. Asked for directions, they were happy to help. Sandwiches are homemade.

Reliably welcoming, friendly, efficient and serving wonderful breakfasts, lunches, cakes, pies, breads & other yummies including Oscar's and Nettle Meadow products!

The owner was impatient for me to order, annoyed by my questions and acted as if I was wasting her time. Terrible service. Will not be back

The sandwich I ordered said it had bacon. No bacon came on the sandwich. I was told the bacon was in the mayo. If it was, I couldn't tell. Nothing was done to remedy the situation.

Super baked goods, beautiful photos of local landmarks and a lovely staff. Plus it's opposite the mosaic wall.

Cannot recommend highly enough! Delicious food, great service, and the very best people!

Always great food and friendly service. Try the grown-up grilled cheese. It's awesome!

Awesome! In the middle of nowhere New York! Check out the mosaic mural on one side of the street then eat here.