PROOF Coffee Roasters

This location fell off a cliff in every way. Was closed for a while for health code violations, then re-opened worse than ever. Staff look like they just rolled out of bed and refuse to even say hello to you. Some of the worst service in a city known for bad service. Always dirty. Badly in need of management intervention. Stay away.

Had a delicious macadamia latte here. The coffee shop was busier than usual but totally worth it for the price and quality.

Smaller than it looks in the photos. WiFi wasn't working. Lemon bread was mediocre. Staff was nice.

EDIT: Adding one star because Jeff took the time to respond to my review. Jeff, my frustration wasn't misguided but reflective of the experience I had in your shop. The wifi wasn't fixed in 1-hour as you suggest (I was there longer than that).

To elaborate, what you see online does not match the vibe of this shop in-person. The pictures look much better than the experience I had in real life. It wasn't spacious. The pastry selection was a struggle. I expected a 4.7 star experience. What I got was less than 3.

However, I can fully appreciate a locally owned business that supports their community. It doesn't change the experience, but I respect the passion and commitment to the empowerment of people through the creation of jobs and Proof's 5% charitable donations.

Maybe it was just a rough day. Will update if I return and have a better experience.

Great espresso. Make sure to try it if you're around Kips Bay!

My favorite coffee shop in the area, maybe even the city! it's so nice and comfy, I feel bad when I have to leave after picking up coffee, the baristas are so friendly. The coffee is great too, the nutella latte is my favorite. Only complaint is that they're not open later on weekends, but it's a great spot to get some work done and enjoy the coffee.

It's just a fake shop with overly roasted cheap coffee beans.
You can't call yourself a specialty store if you don't even know what you are serving. "It's some kind of blend of S.American beans" is not an answer, and, btw, it wasn't even S.American blend, it had notes of Ethiopian coffee.
Lying is BAAAD!
And 2nd, all self respecting specialty storees do pourover coffee!
It's best lying stop in NY, not best coffee shop... 😒

Great spot across the street from Bellevue hospital. Really cute ambiance and wonderful setting. However the coffee is really hit or miss depending on the barista. I used to be able to reliably get a great latte from Proof, but it's been disappointing recently.

Great little coffee nook. Best espresso in the area, well dialed in and rich.

Excellent coffee shop ever I see. Great place to sit and enjoy. Bought coffee to take home and brew as well!

I was just passing through this small resting park, one person sat alone at the table, just enjoying the weather. 🌡️ And it seems nice but also quiet & just listening to the sounds of beauty of Nature. 😌