The Tusten Cup

This is literally the nicest coffee shop I've ever been to. Came here on a whim with my friends before going to a local river. The selection of hot drinks was amazing and my chai latte was perfect. The choice of bagels as well was brilliant. I'd never had a proper New York bagel before and I was not disappointed, my salmon and cream cheese everything bagel was mouthwatering and my friends loved their food as well. The decor is beautiful and the windows overlooking the river are so scenic. Amazing, can't wait to visit next summer!

Nice place for breakfast or lunch overlooking the Delaware river. Order at the counter and the food will be brought to you. Plastic silverware, I’m sure due to Covid but not my fave. The food was good. I was wishing they had some tables set up alongside the windows, so you could see out while eating. The counter person/server got a bit annoyed after she had made a mistake with our dessert. This was an unfortunate ending to our visit but to her credit I will say she appeared to be alone and slightly overwhelmed at the moment.

Let me say that we only had coffee, and no food. Their food menu looks good, and may very well be a good selling point.

The location and ambience of this coffee joint are beautiful - all wooden, green, airy and casual. Friendly faces, outdoor seating on the patio with lovely views. A neat souvenir shop with local baked goods as well as shirts and other goodies.

So why the 3 stars? Their coffee fell really short of expectations. Really unfortunate, as most other aspects seemed so promising. We had issues with both the cold brew and the cappuccino - the former initially had the promised taste of dark chocolate, which quickly turned it into a bitter, watery mess; the latter was just flat out burnt and not even the oat milk could save the drink.

It may have been a bad batch, and your mileage may vary, but purely for coffee I’d recommend other places around - especially because it wasn’t even cheap.

Stopped by The Tusten Cup for breakfast since we were staying at the Blue Fox Motel and it was suggested to us! I really loved the herb cream cheese I had on my everything bagel, and my fiancé enjoyed his truffle shuffle sandwich. Even though it was a rainy day, we enjoyed sitting by the window for the view of the Delaware River. Our food came out quickly, and my fiancé really liked the cortado he had too. Such a nice local spot!

An immaculate experience. Bagels were perfect. Coffee hit the spot. And the views were the cherry on top.

4 stars mostly for location & staff- the view is fantastic, & the photos don't do it justice- you are literally sitting right on top of the water. There is outdoor seating, and it seems very clean & well-designed inside. Such a nice spot! The staff was friendly & service was fast, and the drink portion size was huge! Okay, so now for the cons - the mocha coffee tasted like chocolate milk, not a hint of coffee, (almost like chocolate cereal milk, if that makes sense?) - it was drinkable, but not great. The everything bagel was small, and very salty & bready - not chewy like a NY-style bagel. I asked for some bagels without toppings to take for the next day, & the staff seemed confused by this but finally gave me a few bagels. These were cold & small - I am assuming not fresh, maybe refridged or frozen. The menu seemed pretty extensive, but I don't think I'd order food here again - maybe I would try hot plain coffee just to enjoy the view. My advice to the owner here, would be to keep things fresh/ local/ quality, especially if keeping prices this high- I drove pretty far but I would have def. been a repeat customer if the food & drinks were better.

First let me say what a gorgeous shop and location. Second, I had the caramel latte. When I left I told my husband if we lived closer I would go every day, if not multiple times a day for it. If you love coffee, do yourself a favor and stop by.

This place is amazing! The decor is out of this world! The food selection is incredible. They actually sell edllderberry tea. These guys are great. This by far the absolute best coffee shop I have ever visited. If you are in narrowsburg don't pass this place by without stopping here you deserve to treat yourself to this blessed miracle on the water. The Staff was amazing and most importantly there coffee is SPECTACULAR! I'm so mad at myself for never stopping in this place until today. Tusten cup runs narrowsburg in my opinion.

I stop here when I pass through narrowsburg and look forward to it every time! The honey bee bagel and garden wrap are so delicious. I love that they have golden milk and mud water. It’s sooo so good.

The most wonderful place is the one you feel most at home. This place is it! Whether it's your own backyard or a cozy cabin in the woods, a place where you can relax and be yourself is truly wonderful.