Ice Cream Cafe

Great homemade ice cream and a wide menu. My husband had been talking earlier in the day about the old soda fountains making ice cream floats and lime rickies, which is probably why we decided to go get ice cream in the first place...Ice Cream Cafe has these both on their menu! Nice deck with tables and shade trees is pleasant place to enjoy ice cream.

Outstanding ice cream. There are a lot of great ice cream shops on the cape, however the Ice Cream Cafe stands out from the rest. It's so smooth and wonderfully flavored - they make everything themselves and come up with some really fantastic combinations.

Absolutely incredible spot for ice cream on the Cape with a wonderful and friendly staff willing to let you sample a few different flavors of their homemade ice cream. You can't go wrong with Chocolate Mint Oreo. Nice deck for sitting out back as well.

Really good ice cream! Prices are very decent, I paid less than $6 for a small hot fudge sundae. I recommend going if you are in the Brewster area.

They have no sugar added flavors as good as sugared. Creamy, tasty ice cream with lots of flavors!

Great vegan ice cream options (I had hard ice cream, which was creamy and rich!) including vegan fudge and whipped topping. I don't even want to bother with my local vegan ice cream place now because I'll be soooo disappointed in comparison. The servers were super friendly, too, even though they were very busy. One of the highlights of my trip to the Cape. Thanks. :)

Great ice cream! Very creamy and smooth. we tried the peach and the heath bar coffee flavors, both were terrific. Thete were many flavors to choose from. we will return!

Great local place for dynamite ice cream.

Hand pack, soft serve, and even non dairy options.

Friendly staff, and a load of flavors.
They also have baked goods, and candy if someone isn't in the cool mood.

We love Ice Cream Cafe - we visited each week of our visit this year. Great portions, and a reliable online ordering system. Thank you to the staff for helping us enjoy our time on the Cape during a chaotic year.

Travelers, this is a favorite stop because the ice cream is homemade and delicious. Nothing is better after a hot day at the beach. All the flavors are wonderful. They sell coffee too. We recommend. Enjoy.