Cottage Cafe

Absolutely amazing cakes and pies. Some recipes passed down from generation to generation. The best kept secret in Middletown, KY. This little cafe is run by the sweetest family. Their homemade chicken salad is scrumptious. Light yet tasty and filling. I can't tell you in words alone how decadent everything we purchased and tried was. Highly recommend going to eat here or picking up a nice desert. We purchased the strawberry jelly cake roll. Oh my it was melt in your mouth. If you want a cute story ask about the flamingos! I met Rachael and her mom and they are some really good people. They put their all into their products and reputation. Support you local small businesses but also worth the drive if you aren't local.

BIG, BIG SHOUT OUT to Cottage Cafe!!!
Susie and her staff are absolutely amazing! I called Susie on Thursday to see if she could make an oreo birthday cake that our son requested. She did absolutely an amazing job on such short notice. Cottage Cafe will be my go to for our birthday cakes for now on! It’s homemade from scratch with real whipping cream. It’s huge and so moist - I can go on and on. If you haven’t visited Cottage Cafe in downtown old Middletown go. Thank you Susie! ❤️

The staff! Aces! Unfortunately, they only serve lunch, no breakfast! Fresh cakes!

Wonderful lunch spot, only open from 11 to 3 , take the alley and park in the back, the entrance is in the back. Lunch specials every day, and a small menu, soup, sandwiches, and wonderful dessert place. We had the bacon and benedictine sandwich, deviled eggs, and a hot brown. The a huge piece of marbled cake and coconut pie. The food was large portions and outstanding! I took the chicken salad.and cake home!! Will definitely go back!

Nice little lunch place for a good, home cooked meal. Had the tuna melt, which was served open-faced with a slice of Provolone and a slice of American cheese. My friend had the Benedictine sandwich, which she said was good. Didn't skimp on the Benedictine.

Who loves a BLT? The Cottage Cafe has a great bacon, lettuce, and tomato sandwich! Try it, you won’t be disappointed.

Found this gem the other day. Tried the lunch special. Sandwich was good, but the soup and the desserts were even better! I will be back. Service was awesome. Sometime was always checking to see if I needed anything.

How refreshing and tasty. Also kudos to the nicest attentive staff. This place is everything awesome and then some!

Delicious food and plenty of it!! Got chicken salad, so good and the cakes were so scrumptious. Will be back!! Everyone friendly, like being at a family gathering. Alicia is so sweet!!!

Enjoy the food and staff. Great for a ladies lunch. Chairs aren't the most comfortable.