Search

Amenities

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom
  • Wheelchair accessible seating
  • Outdoor seating
  • Curbside pickup
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Payne's Restaurant Reviews - 100

4.8
Quality
5.0
Location
5.0
Price
4.0
Service
4.5
Muriel Grigsby

Delicious Food! The fish was battered perfectly and light/crispy! Not greasy like other fried foods. The mushy peas tasted extremely fresh! The bean dip was sooo flavorful! The sticky toffee pudding is worth every Penny! We will definitely go back when we are close to Gas City.

Mark T.

Really enjoyed this place! A unique menu, great food, and really friendly staff. This is the kind of place that doesn't look like much from the outside but pays off for those willing to be a little adventurous!

Jake Davis

Great vibe and decor. Fish & chips were good. Rest of our meals were well presented, but we apparently didn't agree with the British flavors / recipes. Glad we tried it though!

Sarah Kennedy

We stopped spur of the moment on our return to Indianapolis from Fort Wayne and loved it! The staff and the atmosphere were fantastic. The food was even better. We had the small Fish & Chips and the Apple Walnut & Brie sandwich. Both were amazing. Highly recommend this place!

cindy mauricio

The waitstaff was friendly and accommodating. Unfortunately one of the male staffers stood and belched loudly near our table as he was getting ready to bus a table. He didn't excuse himself and seemed indifferent to customers. We had the fish and chips. The fish had piece's that were doughy , my drink was delicious.and people seem to enjoy their food. Overall, because of the waitstaff the young lady that gave us great service ,I would give it a second chance.

Rodney h

First time here:Great food, chill atmosphere and fantastic service. The fish and chips is the best I've had this side of the pond.

Second time here: just as good if not better and took the family. You're missing out if you don't give this place a try. So refreshing to find a place like this in a Midwest food wasteland.

Tried bangers and mash this time and the French toast for the kiddos, fire 🔥!

Ron Reichhart

First the service was excellent. I ordered the fish and chips with the potato and onion soup. The soup was interesting and flavorful. My order came out quickly piping hot. I got the medium order that was more than enough to satisfy me with a HUGE fillet. I asked what the large order was. My server said it covered the entire plate. Wow. If you're traveling on I69 jump off at the Gas City exit and look for the Paynes sign.

Kim Carson

Great food and ambiance, moderate pricing. They even had a bloke with a Brit accent waiting on us. Also very handy it doesn’t close between lunch and dinner.

Paul Kern

I've wanted to try this place for awhile. It was excellent! The fish and chips are in my top three all time favorites! And Adam our waiter was awesome! I had the small fish and chips and a house salad and we split a Jenny's Reese's Sunday. If anyone likes fish and chips, this is definitely a good place to try!

Mandy Milner

Delicious food, decent portions. The fish and chips are authentic—definitely a favorite! Love the complimentary black bean dip and chips (if you like the dip, the black bean soup is basically a thinner version of this, and also really yummy with a little kick). They have a nice mix of familiar choices and some out-of-the-box options, so you can be as adventurous as you want to be.

Add Review

Cleanliness
4
Comfort
4
Staff
4
Facilities
4
Your Score
Click here or drop files to upload