Payne's Restaurant

Such a quaint little spot. I brought my husband here for his birthday, as he's not a Hoosier native and hadn't yet experienced the magic of this place. He went for the epic Fish 'n' Chips. The best in the midwest! We enjoyed the outdoor seating so much. The cabanas are where it's at! Service was great. The only reason I didn't go for 5 stars was because my steak was a little underdone and void of seasoning. Being a strip, I expected a little chewy, but it was hard to cut through. And they were out of the Elderflower mimosas which I really love and wanted my husband to try, but the regular orange mimosas were delightful! All and all, a wonderful date night! We will definitely be back in the near future!

For a proper fish and chips or bangers and mash. No Jammie dodgers for desert though. That's all I know about British food but either way, I'm sure they are doing it right. Except they need Jamie dodgers. The doctor once saved the world with a single Jamie dodger. That should say something.

From the eclectic menu to the well-balanced drink selection, Payne's never disappoints. I recommend the smoke trout with greens. Sounds like an odd pairing, but it comes out great!

Wonderful wait staff. The beef stew and Yorkshire pudding are delicious and the best dessert I've ever eaten??..their sticky toffee pudding. Oh! And the restaurant itself is absolutely beautiful!

Awesome fish n chips! Interesting decor & great food all around. Def visit!

Fantastic smoked trout and greens! The beer selection was also good, though they were out of my first choice the waiter made a helpful suggestion for a replacement choice that turned out great. The beef stew with Yorkshire pudding was very good. I even ate the mushrooms that were prepared with it, which is quite the statement since I usually abhor mushrooms. Great food, wonderful service, and a nice atmosphere. I would highly recommend this to everyone!

Absolutely wonderful restaurant, good atmosphere and very authentic.

Absolutely delicious! Great service, wonderful atmosphere, can’t wait to go back! Thank you Payne’s ! Had an amazing experience!

Very friendly staff, tasty grilled cheese and tomato soup, and the bean dip was good too.

A British Pub run by Millennials. So the food is great. I would recommend though that they get rice for the Chicken Curry. The staff tries really hard but there is something awkward here. I am not sure if the sharing community of Millennials meets the needs of the floor staff quite balance out here. Don't get me wrong I love the place but it is very difficult for a restaurant to have a super floor staff. I think if they get the floor staff knowledgeable of what they have to serve and the needs of service it will be a great show.

For now, know what you are ordering and enjoy the great food. The service you can chalk up to entertainment in a good sort of way. Stop by it's worth the visit!

On a side note please mow the lawn and either plant vegetables in the raised garden or take them out. It looks scary!